News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Grand Jury Votes to Indict Donald Trump by rayiner on Saturday April 01, 2023 @06:04PM (#35404583)
Iran actually has a setup similar to the US, where moral issues are removed from the democratic process and turned over to elites. Like the US Supreme Court, Iran’s Guardian Council decides moral issues in consultation with learned experts. Same shit, different religion. Saudi and Afghanistan, meanwhile, aren’t democracies.

And as to Idaho and Texas—who decides where “murder” begins? Me? You? Someone has to, right? What is the rule of decision? Why should post-Christian secular humanism provide the rule of decision instead of regular Christianity, or Islam?

Re:Grand Jury Votes to Indict Donald Trump by tptacek on Saturday April 01, 2023 @06:38PM (#35404864)
Explain why anybody would accept your premise that "Iran actually has a setup similar to the US, where moral issues are removed from the democratic process and turned over to elites"?

The "elites" in Iran are the Shi'a hierarchy. The "elites" in the US are, in your formulation, people who went to college and who live in major US metros. These are not comparable sets. Elite control over US policy is implicit (one might even say supposed); elite control over Iranian policy is explicit and rigidly formalized. These are not comparable notions of "turned over to".

Re:Grand Jury Votes to Indict Donald Trump by rayiner on Sunday April 02, 2023 @09:17AM (#35410201)
In Iran, moral issues are turned over to a Guardian Council of 12 members who are experts in law. The Guardian Council has the power to overturn laws approved by the Parliament. In the US, the Guardian Council, err, Supreme Court, has 9 members who are experts in law, and can overturn laws approved by the federal and state legislatures. Both bodies, moreover, interpret the law according to the moral worldview of their country’s respective elites—from which those legal experts are drawn—even when that departs from the moral worldview of the public in those countries.
Re:Grand Jury Votes to Indict Donald Trump by dctoedt on Saturday April 01, 2023 @06:33PM (#35404826)
> And as to Idaho and Texas—who decides where “murder” begins? Me? You? Someone has to, right?

To a first approximation, Roe got it right.