This presupposes there was a safe place to withdraw to.
> This is the same reason you can't steal something back.
Well, legally you can, at least in most jurisdictions. The property remains yours, and you can do whatever you like with it -- such as pick it up and walk off with it. But you will assume full liability if you injure someone in the process (including the thief) or otherwise make a mistake like taking something that wasn't actually yours.
Texas has "defense of property" being a reason to use lethal force.
If you are not the actual owner in the eyes of the State of Texas and you are driving off with a vehicle, the registered owner can shoot you. It doesn't matter whether you were the original thief or not.
That doesn't make it a good idea, but it is legal in many circumstances.
I would argue that if you have GPS tracking on property, you are always in perpetual pursuit of your items, at minimum for two reasons - first is that you know the item has a propensity for being stolen (obvious), the second is that adding GPS tracking is with the intention you are locating your device at all times, thus you are in a perpetual state of pursuit.
Guy tries to recover the truck from the thief. Thief realizes the gig is up and threatens the guy. Justice ensues.
> Finally, theft doesn't carry the death penalty, and the people whose truck was stolen were not in danger. If the thief drew a gun they should have withdrawn.
This is such a tired cliche. All consequences follow from the criminal's initial action. If things escalate to the point where the criminal aggressor is pulling a gun, they have just made deadly force appropriate. Because that isn't theft, that's aggravated assault and an imminent threat of death.
innocence or guilt isn't determined by applying legal standards to non-judges outside of courthouses, which brings up another point : laws aren't somehow universal to a country, let alone a state. It shouldn't be presumed that a working knowledge of how thing work on average within the United States affords one a working knowledge of how things work in Texas.
There were a lot of presumptions made by the victim, agreed on that. It's fortunate that a non-related party wasn't hurt.
Personally I wouldn't have risked my life for the pursuit of a stolen vehicle, but I can understand the urge.
* They approached their stolen truck
* There was a person in the truck
* They assumed the person in the truck was the thief
* They presumably threatened the occupant
* The occupant responded by drawing a gun
* The shoot the occupant
Now, what happens if their assumption that the occupant is the thief is wrong
* Sitting in truck - maybe you just bought it, maybe it's a friend, coworker, or family members (in this scenario the first option seems implausible, but the others are fine)
* Someone you don't know approaches you
* The person starts accusing you of stealing the truck and threatening you with guns
* You pull out your gun to defend yourself
For the people who found their truck cannot distinguish these two scenarios. It is literally not possible for them to, and in the latter case the occupant of the truck is _defending_ themselves. This is the same reason you can't steal something back.
Finally, theft doesn't carry the death penalty, and the people whose truck was stolen were not in danger. If the thief drew a gun they should have withdrawn.