Should it also be illegal to trade my fake tokens for other fake tokens other via decentralized exchanges?
There is no investor protections in crypto at all, especially if is all retail getting scammed all the time.
> Should it also be illegal to trade my fake tokens for other fake tokens other via decentralized exchanges?
Once it is deemed an unregistered security then yes, it should be illegal and it will be illegal.
There is no way around it once crypto gets pushed down into the dark web where you can only cash out with illegal drugs instead of fiat.
This is where crypto is heading.
Seems to me that FTX's spectacular collapse was a bigger case of looting than what your getting confused with, caused by their own mess rather than the state.
> ...and not supposed investor protections
I fail to see where was investor protections were when FTX and other exchanges collapsed.
> The code for all decentralized exchanges is open source.
Irrelevant.
> You aren’t being scammed by anyone, you volunteered to participate in the market. You aren’t a victim for losing a trade you chose to participate in.
When family members, cousins, in-laws and friends are getting themselves involved with crypto and asking everyone around to bail them out or join, it is a major problem for everyone who knows them.
I’m not in favour of bailouts to anybody, nor taxes that fund those bailouts. Take nobody’s money from them and give nobody’s money to me. Like I said, the code is all open source, you can verify any suspicions you have yourself. There is no scam, you’re just grasping for reasons to regulate other people’s money.
Liquidity for cashing out will begin to dry up and more on other exchanges such as Binance will do the same thing.
Decentralised Exchanges (with absolutely no investor protections, unregulated and are highly prone to rug pulls) will be ordered to shut down, also forcing a drain on liquidity.
Once crypto crashes the market will 'loot' your wallet by deeming your crypto worthless and you will forever try to cash out your worthless coins.
> There is no scam, you’re just grasping for reasons to regulate other people’s money.
It is a scam, just ask the people who lost money with FTX.
Or the many people who have been rug pulled here:
Calling it a scam doesn’t make it a scam. Again, the source is available online, free for you to see. That is the contract you agree to when you choose to participate in crypto. You cannot consent to being scammed, that goes against the very definition of being scammed. Making it illegal for consenting individuals to do what they want is typical authoritarian trash behaviour. Perhaps you’d be happier in Cuba where you can freely control other people’s money to your liking.
Who consented their crypto funds to be lost to rug pulls, ransomware, thefts, hacks, pump and dumps, commingling of funds, and their funds being used for leveraged trading?
So $12+ Billon lost in crypto is not a scam? and the users agreed and consented to all of this?
I'm assuming then that you know some information that suggests that the $12 Billion lost is somehow insured?
> Again, the source is available online, free for you to see.
This doesn't mean anything.
All the people who completely lost their money in FTX, LUNA, BlockFi, etc. do not care about source code. This makes no sense at all. If I was rug pulled in a scam the last thing anyone would care about is the source code.
> That’s cool, I don’t really care though. Leave my money alone,
You will care once liquidity goes dry and once the crypto crackdown ramps up, then all these tokens plus Bitcoin go to zero.
I shouldn't see you moving money or cashing out your crypto because another exchange has fallen down due to regulations or insolvency and the price of these tokens crash.
If you actually get scammed by a proprietary and centralized entity like FTX, then go after FTX and not me. Stop defending the redistribution of consequences, my money is not your basic human right.
This is why what your saying about 'open source' and 'reed the code' is irrelevant.
> You can’t get scammed by an open source project...If you actually get scammed by a proprietary and centralized entity like FTX, then go after FTX and not me.
Wormhole got exploited for $320M even though it was an open source DeFi project, this hack is the 2nd biggest of all time for a DeFi project.
PolyNetwork got exploited for $620M even though it was an open source DeFi project, the biggest of all time.
Where were those reading the code there to stop it?
So when your wallet gets drained are you going to 'reed the code' to reassure yourself that you're not going to get your money back?
> ...then go after FTX and not me. Stop defending the redistribution of consequences, my money is not your basic human right.
It's already happening that FTX is being brought to the law, privacy coins will follow and will be outlawed as they already are from governments around the world.
The law is doing all the work and the precedent for crypto will be set from there.
You can have a tantrum all you want. But you wanted regulation and regulatory clarity, it's coming and it will affect the crypto prices negatively and will tread on your wallet.
As far as I’m concerned, all those exploits were 100% fair game. Again, it’s not a centralized exchange. There is no CEO making promises to you, there are no guarantees. The code you chose to interact with behaved exactly as it was written. That’s what makes crypto unique, there are no “Bitcoin developers”, they don’t have any more power over bitcoin than anyone else. Their changes are only merged in because holders voted those changes in. That’s the very thing that makes it not a security.
Don’t like that? Make better choices next time, or don’t use cryptocurrencies. As I said, that was always an option.
So I'm assuming you know every function and know the control flow of any crypto project or smart contract that your interacting with in detail and reviewing each PR. Unless you use a vulnerability scanner like everybody else and you don't bother reading the code.
The Ronin Network (which is open source) was hacked for $620M even though the code was 'allegedly' solid and those playing Axie Infinity were indirectly affected and lost their money as a result. Where does 'reed the code' fit here?
In the eyes of the law 'reed the code' is a moot point. You can't lose 'money' in the billions and expect no regulation or nothing to happen.
Except if you are in the crypto exchange business and you need to unload your fake tokens for real cash, just like how FTX and other failed exchanges took everyone's money from their wallets when they failed.
When will you stop running from exchange to exchange to try cash out your tokens because of a bank run?