The efforts by WebKit, Chrome, iOS and others simply changed the entire game, and in this game it is pointless to attack flash (silverlight 1.0) or flex (silverlight 2+)
That's what's worrying. The "best and brightest" just played follow the leader to nowhere.
Flash requires you to write it in Actionscript, whereas Sliverlight can be written in any .NET language and ported across. Just because they try to accomplish the same task (getting rich content in your browser) doesn't mean Silverlight is a knock-off.
And at the time Silverlight was developed, there was no major support for the kinds of things Flash/Silverlight did (and for some important things like DRM (think Netflix), there still isn't). It's not always possible to see the things the market is going to grab hold of.
That's the scary part. Microsoft is in charge of its development ecosystem, but it seems to be lying to its developers. They've become much more closed off about releases in the last few years, and it's worrying people.
It really doesn't have much to do with wanting to learn "one true tech." It's more about feeling misled.