Re:Type system of Fortnite's Verse language
by nequo on Thursday March 30, 2023 @04:42PM
(#35378565)
This is textbook bikeshedding. If you have a bias for C syntax, everything else will look niche, weird, or "clearly insane" to you. But there's no reason that we should prefer C's syntactic decisions for assignment and equality operators in a non-C language. Go itself deviated from them, and the authors were instrumental to C itself.
Re:Type system of Fortnite's Verse language
by IshKebab on Thursday March 30, 2023 @05:29PM
(#35379049)
> But there's no reason that we should prefer C's syntactic decisions for assignment and equality operators in a non-C language.
Yes there is - because almost every language uses the same convention, and it's a totally reasonable one. You have to have a really good reason to go against that and I don't see one.
> Go itself deviated from them
Go didn't deviate from the C convention. It just added an extra shorthand operator to simultaneously declare and initialise variables. The meanings of `=` and `==` are the same in Go as in C.
> or "clearly insane" to you
I wasn't saying the use of `=` for equality is clearly insane. `[` is clearly insane for other reasons.
POSIX `[` is clearly insane so let's ignore that.
Which leaves Pascal and OCaml both of which are quite niche.
I think he's right. It's definitely not worth going against the grain with this syntax, and it's debatable if it's even that bad in isolation. I seriously doubt beginners struggle with it.