News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Study Finds Engineers Far More Likely than MBAs to Build ... by jacques_chester on Tuesday January 31, 2012 @09:54PM (#3536423)
I think most MBAs are looking to work for a large company, climb the ladder and so on. The training focuses on that -- it's not called a Masters in Business Administration for the heck of it.
Re:Study Finds Engineers Far More Likely than MBAs to Build ... by ssharp on Tuesday January 31, 2012 @10:07PM (#3536462)
Exactly. MBA programs (traditionally, things are changing slowly) aren't really designed to create entrepreneurs, either.
Re:Study Finds Engineers Far More Likely than MBAs to Build ... by jacques_chester on Tuesday January 31, 2012 @10:10PM (#3536470)
That's not necessarily a bad thing. Large companies need at least some specialist management types.
Re:Study Finds Engineers Far More Likely than MBAs to Build ... by wisty on Tuesday January 31, 2012 @10:52PM (#3536576)
Right, you really need people who can say "OK, no more bullshit on these status reports, just say what happened so we can tell how things are going".

Also, good quantitative skills, and a good understanding of scaling and system behavior are important.

Re:Study Finds Engineers Far More Likely than MBAs to Build ... by coryl on Tuesday January 31, 2012 @10:07PM (#3536461)
Seems like it. I graduated from a business program, the curriculum is generally focused towards fitting into a large or otherwise existant organization.
Re:Study Finds Engineers Far More Likely than MBAs to Build ... by beachgeek on Tuesday January 31, 2012 @09:59PM (#3536437)
That or go work for Wall Street.

I think another issue could just be that Engineers aren't paid as much as MBAs. Which means we need to take that risk if we want to make the bucks.

Also its generally easier for us to take the risk. If you're an engineer making 120K its easier to take a paycut to 100k if you form a startup. If you're an MBA dude making 500K it just doesn't make sense to give up the Rolls etc and take a paycut to 100K.

Re:Study Finds Engineers Far More Likely than MBAs to Build ... by fragsworth on Tuesday January 31, 2012 @11:07PM (#3536616)
120k salaries are typical for engineers though. MBA salaries are probably more varied.
Re:Study Finds Engineers Far More Likely than MBAs to Build ... by beachgeek on Wednesday February 01, 2012 @01:00AM (#3536903)
Yes and no. Some engineers make ~200K to 300K, just for hacking code or selling it. Yes its true :-)

Some MBAs make ~140K out of school. EG McKinsey is known to make you work your tail off for very little $ comparatively speaking. But thats a golden stamp: 4 years out of McKinsey and you could be a SVP at some dumbass BigCo in Silicon Valley making ~500K. Why the hell would you want to give it up and join/form a startup?

Re:Study Finds Engineers Far More Likely than MBAs to Build ... by jonnathanson on Wednesday February 01, 2012 @09:11AM (#3537952)
The job market has been exerting a lot of downward pressure on MBA salaries in recent years, especially in the wake of the financial crisis. While it's still possible for a newly minted MBA grad to make somewhere close to $140k at McKinsey, or more at an investment bank, most MBA grads are falling moderately to significantly south of that figure.

And, as others have noted, the starting salaries are highly variable -- by school, by industry, and especially by job function. When people speak of "average" MBA salaries, they're usually speaking of a mean figure and not a median -- which is a bit silly, because the mean has traditionally been skewed very heavily by investment bankers.

At the end of the day, it's somewhat intellectually lazy to compare "MBAs" to "Engineers," as if both sets are relatively homogenous, or even normally distributed. The fact is, the designation "MBA" could mean so many different things. It could mean a nonprofit manager earning $65k, a brand manager earning $80k, a consultant earning $120k, or a private equity associate earning $200k+. To a certain extent, the same can be said of the broad category "Engineer" -- although there are so many subspecies of "Engineering" masters degrees, that selecting any one of them can yield a more homogenous set to work with.

In the long run, one thing seems abundantly clear: there are perhaps more MBAs entering the job market each year than the job market will actually bear. Conversely, there is a dearth of engineering talent, and a consequent seller's market in most engineering fields. That means engineering salaries will likely trend higher, while MBA salaries trend lower.

Re:Study Finds Engineers Far More Likely than MBAs to Build ... by beachgeek on Wednesday February 01, 2012 @02:28PM (#3539494)
Probably. All of my information is from a conversation I had with a newly minted Wharton MBA circa 2007.

Also with just seeing how things operate in the Valley. I haven't seen McKinsey around a lot here though...which may be a good thing. Back in the tech bust years, they seemed to have just one piece of advice for every problem: outsource to India :-)