News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Teen Mental Illness Epidemic Is International, Part 1... by EntrePrescott on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @04:37PM (#35363188)
That article (i.e. the author) seems to have a weird understanding of mathematics:

> "Note that there are two ways to calculate increases. We can measure an increase in absolute terms, e.g., a rise from 5% to 15% of teens with a diagnosis is a ten percentage-point increase, or we can report it in relative terms, e.g., a rise from 5% to 15% is a 300% increase, relative to the anchor point"

Uhm… maybe in an "alternative mathematics" universe? Where I learned math, an increase from 100% of the anchor value to 300% of the anchor value is not a relative increase of 300% but of 300%-100%=200%.

In contrast, A "300% increase, relative to the anchor point" would be an increase of 300% of the anchor value i.e. from 100% to 100%+300%=400% of that value, so in this case, to come back to the absolute terms, an rise from 5% to 20%.

Re:The Teen Mental Illness Epidemic Is International, Part 1... by sbirch on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @05:43PM (#35364178)
I think you've mixed up relative and absolute differences. Both of your examples are in terms of absolute percentage points (pp, sometimes ambiguously labeled %), but relative changes are measured in percent (%). 300% relative difference just means 300/100 = 3x.
Re:The Teen Mental Illness Epidemic Is International, Part 1... by EntrePrescott on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @06:49PM (#35364976)
> Both of your examples are in terms of absolute percentage points

No, they are both about relative increases. I didn't even mention absolute increases because (unlike relative increases, where it makes a mistake) absolute increases were the part that the article got right: a rise from 5% to 15% would be an (absolute) increase of 10% … just like the article says.

> 300% relative difference just means 300/100 = 3x

…My point was: 300% relative INCREASE (i.e. positive relative difference) means that it's the DIFFERENCE (increase) between the initial value and the end value that is 300% RELATIVE TO the initial value (thus the end value being 400% of the initial value), not that the end value is 300% of the initial value (which would only be a 200% relative increase).

Let's take, to better illustrate the point, an example with a relative increase below 100%. Let's go with an example with 40% relative increase. So let's say:

* Last year, your company made a profit of 5 million dollars out of a revenue of 100 million dollars, i.e. a profit margin of 5%.

* This year it still made a revenue of 100 million dollars but managed to be more profitable, making a profit of 7 million dollars i.e. a profit margin of 7%.

* The ABSOLUTE increase of the profit margin is (7%-5%)=2%,

* The RELATIVE increase of profit margin is the absolute increase of profit margin divided by its initial reference value i.e. (7%-5%)/5% = 40%.

And my point is: having a 40% relative increase of profit margin means that your end profit margin is 40% higher relative to your initial reference profit margin and is thus (100%+40%)=140% of your initial reference profit margin, not that your end profit margin is 40% of your initial profit margin… which would be a 60% relative DECREASE (i.e. -60% relative increase) of the profit margin.