News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pause Giant AI Experiments: An Open Letter by mrguyorama on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @04:00PM (#35362560)
It's like the google researcher who claimed their model was sentient because he heavily coached it to give the output he wanted and ignored the output that didn't confirm his belief.

In that case, we've had AGI since ELIZA

If this was the standard in other areas of science we would still be using the miasma theory of medicine and bloodletting women for their hysteria. AI "Research" is a bunch of motivated people throwing stuff at the wall and claiming something sticking means they are scientists. Nevermind all of the groups are HEAVILY motivated to overhype their models.

Re:Pause Giant AI Experiments: An Open Letter by HybridCurve on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @05:51PM (#35364276)
People are also quick to aggrandize or anthropomorphize these systems as well because they lack a fundamental understanding of the underlying mathematics or mechanisms which allow these models to function as well as they do. There is an inherent danger in how much trust people are willing to grant to something like a language(or image) model simply because it is so adept at synthesis.

This is a great cause of concern to me, especially when it is not particularly difficult to invalidate general credibility of these models. In the near future, it will not be as easy and I anticipate many(even the well educated) will surrender their rationale to these systems easily with little to no scrutiny.

The hype from these companies is contributing to this problem and I consider it to be highly unethical.