News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Apple Boycott: People Are Spouting Nonsense about Chi... by tptacek on Tuesday January 31, 2012 @06:16PM (#3535716)
I don't understand the argument here. If the issue is morality, then an effective boycott of Apple products harms Chinese workers, because nobody is working at Foxconn instead of some better latent opportunity in the Chinese economy.

If Apple paid workers the prevailing wage for US skilled labor, Apple would not be paying workers in China at all, because the discount on labor is the primary reason it outsources to China.

One looks at the spread between Apple's COGS and Apple's list prices and wonders how it can be reasonable that Apple captures that whole spread. But that's why we have markets: over time, wage pressure erodes Apple's margins; Foxconn (or comparable companies) obtain better clients, or are simply forced to increase their cost because of competition from other firms.

When Apple responds to that pressure by finding another third world country to buy from, it's simply repeating the same process in that country: unless they source forced labor from Myanmar or North Korea, the only way they can get labor is by improving the wages that were already available in that country.

Part of the issue here seems to be the (unreasonable) expectation that one company can fix third-world rural poverty instantly. Improving the lives of millions of people in Asia is a process that will involve many, many countries and take many decades.

Re:The Apple Boycott: People Are Spouting Nonsense about Chi... by dasil003 on Tuesday January 31, 2012 @07:10PM (#3535926)
> Part of the issue here seems to be the (unreasonable) expectation that one company can fix third-world rural poverty instantly.

I think you've hit the nail on the head here. It's easy to hate big corporations, but even if you make the argument that they are exploiting workers, what are the alternatives?

If Americans truly have a moral responsibility to improve Chinese lives, then actually what is necessary is a foreign policy that directly aims to level the playing field between the countries. It might be something effectively akin to an international progressive tax, I don't know what form it would take, but the point is that Americans would never stand for this. People are already complaining daily about losing their jobs to overseas workers, and the entire culture—both cultures I believe—are based on competition. Corporations are just a handy scapegoat to assuage our liberal guilt.

Re:The Apple Boycott: People Are Spouting Nonsense about Chi... by cdavid on Wednesday February 01, 2012 @02:54AM (#3537130)
A boycott may be effective to improve working conditions. The difference between a US factory and a foxcon factory is not a binary thing: surely, nobody would argue that increasing the wages of those workers of say 0.0001 % will make their situation worse. Would 0.01 % ? etc… How much would it cost Apple to make sure they can use alcohol instead instead of n-hexane ? So while it is indeed not feasable to have working conditions similar to the West from day one, it certainly is to improve their conditions. If it ends up costing less to Apple than the PR issue of not to, Apple will do it.

Also, the article that was everywhere last week showed how the advantage of Chinese factories was not just low wages, but a capacity to get a new production line in no time. This pust those factories at an advantage, and gives them a large bargaining power. I would not be surprised that this kind of advantages will actually be used as a bargaining chip by some chinese local gvt to force Apple to contribute to working conditions improvements. Because Apple cannot produce ipods tomorrow in Vietnam.

Re:The Apple Boycott: People Are Spouting Nonsense about Chi... by nekojima on Tuesday January 31, 2012 @06:31PM (#3535782)
"One looks at the spread between Apple's COGS and Apple's list prices and wonders how it can be reasonable that Apple captures that whole spread."

Because COGS is what Apple pays Foxconn (and other manufacturers) to produce those items. Foxconn and the others make their profit (or loss) from the contracted amount paid, which is roughly, though not always, COGS.

It is far more likely Apple would contract factories in Vietnam and Indonesia than in Burma or North Korea to product items, as forced labour is a poor source of quality manufactured goods.

Re:The Apple Boycott: People Are Spouting Nonsense about Chi... by MartinCron on Tuesday January 31, 2012 @07:51PM (#3536064)
an effective boycott of Apple products harms Chinese workers

The very threat of a boycott will put yet more pressure on Apple to at least appear to improve the conditions while still employing factory workers.