News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Apple Boycott: People Are Spouting Nonsense about Chi... by brudgers on Tuesday January 31, 2012 @05:31PM (#3535516)
>"That’s what being poor means, having to work extremely hard to make very little."

"Being poor" means not having very much money.

Working extremely hard to make very little, when one does not care for the work and has little practical alternative is being exploited.

This is or is not to say that Apple or Foxconn is exploiting the workers.

The argument attributed to Krugman is essentially the same argument that was advanced in opposition to divestiture in apartheid South Africa in the 1980's - that economic exploitation is better than change.

Re:The Apple Boycott: People Are Spouting Nonsense about Chi... by yummyfajitas on Tuesday January 31, 2012 @08:51PM (#3536249)
Krugman's argument does not apply to apartheid.

I'll make an analogy. If you are punching someone, I might punch you back. In the short run, this action harms both your face and my hand, and I might accidentally step on your victim in the process. Counterproductive, right? But in the long run, it provides you an incentive to stop punching the victim, and they wind up better off. Similarly, economic sanctions against South Africa would harm everyone in South Africa (including the victims), but might cause the ruling elite to change their behavior.

In contrast, if you are sick, punching you won't help. You are now more motivated to get beterbut so what? There is no simple action you can take to become better. Sanctions against China or Foxconn are closer to this situation - there is no simple action they can take to stop being poor.

Interestingly, I've been told by a couple of black South African that life was indeed better in many ways under apartheid. As it was described to me, "at least under apartheid, if your sister gets gang raped, the cops will beat down the N* who did it." (Very rough quote, I'm remembering a conversation from 2004.)

(Side note: isn't it surprising to read old Krugman? These days it's easy to forget that he was once an economist.)

Re:The Apple Boycott: People Are Spouting Nonsense about Chi... by brudgers on Wednesday February 01, 2012 @10:14AM (#3538247)
Yes, yes, Krugman's argument does not apply to apartheid.

It is the logical form of his argument which parallels the form of arguments made against divestiture in the apartheid regime. The logical form of the argument may be summed up as "the possibility of distant perverse effects outweighs the value of more immediate virtuous effects."

A analogy would be, we have a contract which requires me to pay you in cash. When you come to receive payment, I refuse to pay cash on the grounds that you might become infected by a virus on one of the bills.

Re:The Apple Boycott: People Are Spouting Nonsense about Chi... by tptacek on Tuesday January 31, 2012 @06:09PM (#3535684)
I don't understand the point you're trying to make here. In what sense is Foxconn's average wage comparable to South African Apartheid? Nobody in China is forced to accept a job at Foxconn; in fact, if Apple produced goods the way its critics appear to want it to, they wouldn't even have the option of working for Foxconn wages, because Apple's manufacturing would take place in the US.
Re:The Apple Boycott: People Are Spouting Nonsense about Chi... by brudgers on Tuesday January 31, 2012 @06:23PM (#3535750)
First point:

The author is mistaken. One can be poor without suffering exploitation in the labor market.

Second point:

Krugman argues that wages should not be raised (which is presumably the course demanded by our conscience) because it might hurt the very people we seek to help.

"And it might not even do that. The advantages of established First World industries are still formidable. The only reason developing countries have been able to compete with those industries is their ability to offer employers cheap labor. Deny them that ability, and you might well deny them the prospect of continuing industrial growth, even reverse the growth that has been achieved. And since export-oriented growth, for all its injustice, has been a huge boon for the workers in those nations, anything that curtails that growth is very much against their interests. A policy of good jobs in principle, but no jobs in practice, might assuage our consciences, but it is no favor to its alleged beneficiaries."

This is the same logic which underlay the arguments against divestiture - i.e. that exploitation is preferable to some imagined alternative form of suffering.

Third point:

Foxconn et al may or may not be exploiting workers.

Re:The Apple Boycott: People Are Spouting Nonsense about Chi... by jamesaguilar on Tuesday January 31, 2012 @07:39PM (#3536028)
> Working extremely hard to make very little, when one does not care for the work and has little practical alternative is being exploited.

Subsistence farming matches this pattern. You have to work very hard, you make very little, and you don't like the work. It doesn't make much sense to label that exploitation since no one is there to exploit you (are you exploiting yourself?). But let's roll with it.

At least with Foxconn in the picture, these folks have one alternative. Put another way, Foxconn is at least less exploitative by your definition than what is likely the main alternative for many of its workers. But I suspect that your definition is not exactly the same as what you believe exploitation really is.