News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UK Sets Up Fake Booter Sites to Muddy DDoS Market by joosters on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @02:05PM (#35345288)
Clever idea!

I wonder why they chose to tell the users when they registered, instead of waiting? Could they have gone ahead and let them place orders for DDOS attacks, to capture more proof of the users' criminal intent, or would that count as entrapment? Someone who 'merely' registered could try to claim that they were a researcher, but if you hit the button to DDoS someone, that's going to be more difficult to deny responsibility for.

[Edit: Now that's making me imagine a disgruntled user suing the NCA for breach of contract: "I paid money for a DDoS and they didn't provide the service!"]

Re:UK Sets Up Fake Booter Sites to Muddy DDoS Market by gs17 on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @02:29PM (#35345685)
Unless the UK is very different, it shouldn't be entrapment to let them try to buy it. IANAL, but in the US, entrapment as a defense requires "the defendant's lack of predisposition to engage in the criminal conduct".
Re:UK Sets Up Fake Booter Sites to Muddy DDoS Market by iudqnolq on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @02:53PM (#35346027)
Which, by the way, is absolute bullcrap. A classic example is an undercover telling people at a methadone clinic that they've been cut off because of a paperwork snafus and begging people to share their legally prescribed methadone so they don't go into withdrawal. Because anyone at a clinic treating drug use has a predisposition to use illegal drugs, it can't be entrapment.
Re:UK Sets Up Fake Booter Sites to Muddy DDoS Market by cdot2 on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @03:05PM (#35346204)
Your sentence is confusing because of the unclear use of "they". It sounds like in this case an undercover cop would come to someone asking for their controlled drugs and you're arguing that it should be entrapment.
Re:UK Sets Up Fake Booter Sites to Muddy DDoS Market by r3trohack3r on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @05:28PM (#35348167)
> and you're arguing that it should be entrapment

I'd agree with this in principle.

If a citizen approaches an undercover cop and offers to sell their controlled substances that isn't entrapment.

If an undercover cop approaches someone and asks to purchase their controlled substances that should be entrapment.

Police shouldn't be able to ask you if you want to commit a crime, it muddies the water of intent. If the police hadn't initiated the crime by asking, would the citizen still have still done the illegal thing?

Standing up a honeypot is different. If someone is actively searching for a good or service and initiates contact with the honeypot, intent is clear.

For me, part of this is "give an inch they take a mile." Letting police ask you to commit a crime is an inch. Then the police get convincing with lines like "my babies are at home, we cant make rent and I cant afford formula. I'm trying to get clean anyways, can I sell you my 8ball for some cash? No no, I can't accept charity. No no, I don't have anything else to sell." Perhaps the citizen doesn't do drugs, has no intention of doing drugs, and is foolish enough to think they can give this person cash and toss the drugs in the nearest trash can once out of sight. Instead they're getting handcuffed because a police officer pulled at their heartstrings and tricked them into "buying drugs."

Re:UK Sets Up Fake Booter Sites to Muddy DDoS Market by GauntletWizard on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @09:58PM (#35351135)
So, any conviction that starts off with "that guy over there is my dealer", then the cop goes over and asks to buy drugs, the dealer flashes open his coat, those should be thrown out for entrapment?

To put it politely, No thanks. I'd prefer it to keep working as it does.

Re:UK Sets Up Fake Booter Sites to Muddy DDoS Market by iudqnolq on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @09:17PM (#35350723)
The undercover cop is asking people for controlled prescription drugs. The cop claims they have a medical need and a prescription. The cop says the only reason they can't get the meds legally is one of the standard system errors that delay getting drugs in this country.

Let's call the person giving the drugs Sally. If Sally has a previous conviction for drug-related crimes this isn't entrapment. If Sally has no criminal record it is entrapment and she walks free. I think she should walk free regardless, i.e. it's always entrapment.

Re:UK Sets Up Fake Booter Sites to Muddy DDoS Market by tptacek on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @08:08PM (#35350027)
The UK is very different: there is no general defense of "entrapment" in UK criminal law.
Re:UK Sets Up Fake Booter Sites to Muddy DDoS Market by pbhjpbhj on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @02:23PM (#35361177)
It's written somewhat in jargon but the CPS gives guidance in the section Entrapment on https://www.cps.gov.uk/legal-guidance/abuse-process.

It's relatively readable, it's probably enough to note that a "stay" means that a trial will not proceed (at all).

A quote from that section:

"Police conduct which brings about state-created crime is unacceptable and improper, and to prosecute in such circumstances would be an affront to the public conscience. However, if the accused already had the intent to commit a crime of the same or a similar kind, and the police did no more than give him the opportunity to fulfil his existing intent, that is unobjectionable."

Re:UK Sets Up Fake Booter Sites to Muddy DDoS Market by burnished on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @02:15PM (#35345454)
I suspect the idea was to discourage instead of entrap/punish. I guess I'm also curious about the rationale, was it a strategic decision, a humane one, or a legal one? All of the above?

Maybe as simple as the action being illegal and since they are not providing the advertised service then no crime is committed? I don't know how broadly applicable this is but in at least one state the local drinking laws boil down to 'you will not serve minors', perhaps something similar here.

Re:UK Sets Up Fake Booter Sites to Muddy DDoS Market by Analemma_ on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @02:19PM (#35345505)
It probably would also help with investigations too. If Joe Bloggs tried to sign up to attack bobsforum.com, got warned off by one of these services, and then a couple weeks later bobsforum.com had an actual attack, they’re probably going to knock on Joe Bloggs’ door first.
Re:UK Sets Up Fake Booter Sites to Muddy DDoS Market by owisd on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @02:26PM (#35345623)
Probably deliberate, for most a warning and a stern phone call will probably be enough to convince them not to try it again so if preventing crime rather than getting convictions is your goal then it's done its job.

It wouldn't be entrapment unless the NCA was proactively coercing people into placing orders. (you can't have a contract for something illegal so there'd be no right of action)

Re:UK Sets Up Fake Booter Sites to Muddy DDoS Market by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @02:12PM (#35345396)
Besides entrapment, I could imagine that they do genuinely want to increase awareness that it's illegal (meh, "in the majority of countries"). It's more about discouraging people from using such services so they're likely not looking to prosecute the, so far, several thousand people who have tried to sign up for the services.
Re:UK Sets Up Fake Booter Sites to Muddy DDoS Market by Consumer8735 on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @02:10PM (#35345363)
They probably monitored the communities that talk about these services and figured that suspicions were growing. Also if you say that there are more services out there, then it makes people think twice.
Re:UK Sets Up Fake Booter Sites to Muddy DDoS Market by tmpz22 on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @02:08PM (#35345333)
A lot of them are kids, students, etc. Gamers are a major demographic for this stuff.