News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:WEKA Responds to Unfounded Allegations Made by MinIO Rega... by tensor on Monday March 27, 2023 @03:55PM (#35331537)
If you are in the business of making money like minio, you may as well just use a commercial license. No business will touch AGPL, they will just opt to pay for a commercial license.
Re:WEKA Responds to Unfounded Allegations Made by MinIO Rega... by phoronixrly on Monday March 27, 2023 @04:41PM (#35332218)
In fact, I am starting to ask myself the opposite... 'Since project X is MIT-licensed, do they need my contribution at all? Probably not, their license probably brings them many high-quality corporate contributions.'
Re:WEKA Responds to Unfounded Allegations Made by MinIO Rega... by jenadine on Monday March 27, 2023 @04:12PM (#35331776)
> No business will touch AGPL

That's not true, I am in contact with many business using AGPL software. (Not Minio specifically)

Some businesses choose not to touch it, but that's their losses.

Re:WEKA Responds to Unfounded Allegations Made by MinIO Rega... by akvadrako on Monday March 27, 2023 @05:00PM (#35332525)
That's kinda why the AGPL is good; it lets non-businesses and open-source companies use it and encourages closed companies to purchase a license.
Re:WEKA Responds to Unfounded Allegations Made by MinIO Rega... by dilyevsky on Monday March 27, 2023 @10:39PM (#35335162)
It’s not good bc it ties survivability of a project with a single company. If company folds so does your open-source project. Also imagine if linux wouldn’t be able to receive contributions from google and other big tech
Re:WEKA Responds to Unfounded Allegations Made by MinIO Rega... by akvadrako on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @03:24AM (#35337060)
That only works because Linux is run by customers, which the GPL covers, instead of provided as a web service. The AGPL is needed to encourage the same contributions for SASS products.
Re:WEKA Responds to Unfounded Allegations Made by MinIO Rega... by dilyevsky on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @11:01AM (#35342201)
> That only works because Linux is run by customers, which the GPL covers

You’d be shocked to find out but linux is also run by cloud providers and offered as a service (in the form of VMs).

And unfortunately because of murky water of what constitutes “derivative work” in agpl (case in point - see the title of this thread) most companies won’t ever touch agpl licensed projects