Re:140 Megapixel Picture of the Sun
by mncharity on Monday March 27, 2023 @07:51AM
(#35325481)
> does not really mean much here [...] impossible to directly observe
As misconceptions are common around the Sun, sunlight, and colour, it can be helpful to crosscheck concepts by swapping the Sun for a more familiar object: a light bulb, display, wall, shirt, or elephant.
Imagine an article about a newly energy-efficient light bulb, which included only false-color thermal and near IR images - "Look, less waste heat and wasted light!". Would it seem odd to suggest adding a true-color visible-light photo? What if the authors color graded such a photo to hide a less marketable, say greenish cast?
Years ago, NASA did a traveling museum exhibit on the Sun with lots of colorful images, but not a single white Sun. Now imagine a traveling exhibit on elephants. With colorful thermal IR images of ears as radiators, and false-color images of skin parasite distribution (thus mud baths) and so on. But not a single grey elephant. How odd would that be?
Presented with "A 5-year old asks: The Sun is a big hot ball... what color is the ball?", it's not uncommon for first-tier-U physical-sciences graduate students to answer with variations on "it doesn't have a color; it's lots of different colors; it's rainbow color", reflecting misconceptions around color perception. Which then might be probed with "A 5-year old asks: what color is that shirt?".
"Why does the Sun shine? Fusion!" becomes "Why does the LED light bulb shine? Electricity!", highlighting the incompleteness.
Another crosscheck is seeing how the non-uniform appearance of the Sun (limb darkening) is handled. With the edge/limb appearing darker and redder because of longer sight lines through cooler higher layers.
As misconceptions are common around the Sun, sunlight, and colour, it can be helpful to crosscheck concepts by swapping the Sun for a more familiar object: a light bulb, display, wall, shirt, or elephant.
Imagine an article about a newly energy-efficient light bulb, which included only false-color thermal and near IR images - "Look, less waste heat and wasted light!". Would it seem odd to suggest adding a true-color visible-light photo? What if the authors color graded such a photo to hide a less marketable, say greenish cast?
Years ago, NASA did a traveling museum exhibit on the Sun with lots of colorful images, but not a single white Sun. Now imagine a traveling exhibit on elephants. With colorful thermal IR images of ears as radiators, and false-color images of skin parasite distribution (thus mud baths) and so on. But not a single grey elephant. How odd would that be?
Presented with "A 5-year old asks: The Sun is a big hot ball... what color is the ball?", it's not uncommon for first-tier-U physical-sciences graduate students to answer with variations on "it doesn't have a color; it's lots of different colors; it's rainbow color", reflecting misconceptions around color perception. Which then might be probed with "A 5-year old asks: what color is that shirt?".
"Why does the Sun shine? Fusion!" becomes "Why does the LED light bulb shine? Electricity!", highlighting the incompleteness.
Another crosscheck is seeing how the non-uniform appearance of the Sun (limb darkening) is handled. With the edge/limb appearing darker and redder because of longer sight lines through cooler higher layers.