In my recollection, scheduled wisdom tooth extraction has usually been on the same 50% co-pay as emergency wisdom tooth extraction. And I don't think the "emergency" part has the cost implications in dental that it does in other medical realms.
Neither is pleasant, but the cost would probably be the same either way. I don't try to justify the tiering of the co-pay, but recognize that moving it down to the 20% co-pay range just means the actuaries factor that change into everyone's premium.
You said "typically (not always)" and I say pretty close to never.
I don't try to justify the tiering of the co-pay
You said the co-pay was tiered "because such procedures are typically (not always) preventable" (emphasis mine).
(i'm note 100% sure that by 'tiered' you mean that you pay 50% for this instead of the flat or 0 co-pay most dental coverage has for checkups and the like)
If I were trying to explain the rationale in this case, I'd theorize it's because this is typically something that happens once in a lifetime (if at all). I'd expect once one wisdom tooth gets cranky, they'd yank the rest at the same time. So, in this case, the thought would be that people partially pay for it when it happens rather than making everyone in the insurance pool pay for that risk every month, especially people with no wisdom teeth.
But I am not an actuary or insurer, so I don't know for sure.
Dental insurance is pretty cheap -- there are a limited number of high-dollar procedures that happen infrequently. Plus, major costs like anesthesia are usually part of medical coverage. So while the insurance pool is more likely to pay for a wisdom extraction for many folks between 18 and 30, that's a one time event.
Medical insurance, on the other hand, needs to cover a broad array of overpriced procedures with nearly unlimited liability. I had a back surgery that cost my insurance company about $75k. The recent birth of my child cost nearly $25k!
Dentists far too often recommend extraction for wisdom teeth when it's unnecessary, probably because they can charge a hefty fee for it.
These things are not preventable, you were just born lucky. Remember, humans didn't usually live to become 50 years old.
Exactly this. I had something similar (identical?): A horizontal impaction of my bottom right molar. Had I left it longer, it would've destroyed the roots to the molar in front of it, and I would've lost that tooth, too.
I suspect it's largely genetic. My mum has all her wisdom teeth, and she's never had an issue; my father had all of his removed because they didn't come in straight. My situation played out identically to his. Hence, I don't believe that simply taking pristine care of the teeth will magically help--if they don't erupt from the gums properly or come in crooked, there isn't much else that can be done save an extraction if they're problematic. In many cases, you're better off having them removed to prevent issues precisely like this one.
(On a tangent, there's a great article [1] about how bulldogs have been bread to have massive jaws and a very short face and that results in all kinds of breathing difficulties.)
[0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hypodontia [1] http://www.nytimes.com/2011/11/27/magazine/can-the-bulldog-b...
> (On a tangent, there's a great article [1] about how bulldogs have been bread to have massive jaws and a very short face and that results in all kinds of breathing difficulties.)
I bet that applies to persian cats, too, since they're bred with extensively concave faces (something that seems cruel, IMO).
Very interesting reply--thanks for sharing that, because I had completely forgotten that one of my friends has a similar condition. Can't believe I completely forgot he had implantation done, too...
This. Also, humans used to lose a lot of teeth. Modern dental hygiene is a very recent development within the ~200,000 year span of H. sapiens sapiens. Throughout most of human history, wisdom teeth served as reserves, of a sort, to fill in what were likely to have been more than a few gaps.
These days, proper dental hygiene means you've more likely than not been able to keep all of your adult teeth, ergo, it's highly likely than your wisdom teeth will become impacted. The assertion that proper dental care will prevent wisdom tooth impaction is ludicrous.
It is true, however, that extraction of wisdom teeth can be managed to an extent. Almost everyone gets them at some point, and impaction is very common, and all of this is well known. So a proper dental regimen should include x-rays to search for wisdom teeth well before they become problematic. If this is what the OP intended to say, then fine. But his phrasing makes it sound as if he implied that proper brushing and flossing will obviate the need for wisdom tooth removal. Last I checked, brushing and flossing do not alter the shape of one's jaw.
> My wisdom teeth actually fit in my mouth. Because
> I took care of them
I think this is the point of contention...Whether or not your wisdom teeth fit into your mouth or grow in the right direction is not a matter of 'proper dental hygiene.'
Wait, what? It's true that under most dental coverage you pay a percentage (and not a flat co-pay) on oral surgery, but for the life of me, I don't understand the idea that the need for wisdom tooth extraction is ever preventable by proper dental care. No amount of brushing and flossing is going to prevent your body from throwing extra teeth in your mouth in your late 20s.
If anything, proper dental care means none of your teeth will have fallen out, so when your wisdom teeth come in they have nowhere to go and get impacted and then decayed and then infected.