News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I Was Just Told “You would not have made it through the w... by aiscott on Monday January 30, 2012 @09:01PM (#3531455)
Healthcare is a scarce resource. You can hardly legislate it into existence. All "universal" healthcare does is trade price for waiting in line.
Re:I Was Just Told “You would not have made it through the w... by jrmg on Tuesday January 31, 2012 @03:48AM (#3532423)
As someone form a country with a working, good, universal health care system, the notion that many Americans have that it somehow can't work in reality is very puzzling to me. How can that be true when it plainly does work in many places?

The argument that a private insurance based system could be better, fairer, or more efficient can be made (although not if you hold up the current US system as a positive example...), but any argument that it's the only thing that will work is frankly ludicrous.

Re:I Was Just Told “You would not have made it through the w... by InclinedPlane on Tuesday January 31, 2012 @04:45AM (#3532540)
Define "does work".

Healthcare in the US, even in its incredibly broken state, still "does work". We can compare anecdotes all day long, but that tells us nothing, anecdotes are not data.

Re:I Was Just Told “You would not have made it through the w... by jrmg on Tuesday January 31, 2012 @06:04AM (#3532754)
I believe it's generally known to be true that health care in the UK, where I live now (I have also lived in the USA in the past), whether measured by % of GDP or by monetary cost, is much cheaper per capita than health care in the USA[1]. Life expectancy, probably a good measure of the efficacy of a health care system, is very close, perhaps with the UK having a small lead, if anything[2].

If we were to allow anecdotes, I'd also say (and I find this to be a good thing) that people in the UK don't avoid going to the dentist or doctor because it's too expensive. I'm sure that there must be studies that show this to be true.

Even if we're not allowing the anecdotal argument, however, if you're prepared to say that the system in the USA 'does work', you're surely prepared to say that the British system also works? Personally, I have a hard time not believing that, since it seems to produce comparable, if not better outcomes, for less cost, it's the better of the two systems.

Note that I'm /not/ arguing at all that a private health insurance system could not be devised that also worked as well - perhaps better. I'm also not arguing that any public system will be perfect. To argue that a public system /can't work/ though is, as I said, ludicrous.

[1] http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=health+care+cost+per+ca... [2] http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=life+expectancy+USA+vs+...

Re:I Was Just Told “You would not have made it through the w... by carbocation on Tuesday January 31, 2012 @10:56AM (#3533756)
Until we have a cure for the metabolic syndrome, I'd say that comparison of health care quality by life expectancy doesn't actually do what you think it does. America is incredibly obese, and this is a lifestyle choice that makes comparisons of the quality of care quite difficult.
Re:I Was Just Told “You would not have made it through the w... by jrmg on Tuesday January 31, 2012 @04:33PM (#3535304)
Fair point, but can you find another statistic that /would/ show that public healthcare doesn't work?
Re:I Was Just Told “You would not have made it through the w... by carbocation on Tuesday January 31, 2012 @04:43PM (#3535342)
I wouldn't even try to make the argument that public healthcare doesn't work. Comparing across systems and cultures (again, obese vs the rest of the world) is tough to do well. I was thinking perhaps some measure of in-hospital mortality would be useful, but even that would be confounded. Perhaps the Massachusetts model might work for in-US comparison to other states, but MA is not really comparable to single payer systems in the rest of the world.

It's a really interesting topic and I wish I weren't at work so I could brainstorm more with you about how to get a clean comparison.

Re:I Was Just Told “You would not have made it through the w... by ohyes on Tuesday January 31, 2012 @08:19PM (#3536158)
It is a talking point from our country's politicians (who already have what would be offered under a real universal healthcare bill) who are in the pocket of private insurance companies, big pharma, and the like.

Call me a cynic if you like, but that is the only real argument I can think of. There is no data to back the claim up, only anecdotes about what it's like in other countries.

The data points to universal healthcare being better.

Re:I Was Just Told “You would not have made it through the w... by yequalsx on Monday January 30, 2012 @09:15PM (#3531492)
Healthcare is a scarce resource but what you say isn't all that universal healthcare provides. All healthcare systems must ration care. The goal is to ration care in the most ethical/moral way. The present system in the U.S. rationalizes care in a more unethical way that Finland and other similar healthcare systems.
Re:I Was Just Told “You would not have made it through the w... by rayiner on Monday January 30, 2012 @10:33PM (#3531702)
This sort of hyper-simplistic modeling of real world problems is a pretty common trait among real academics, not just HN posters. In my own field of interest (spectrum management) the papers written by ostensibly reputable people are shockingly bad in their reductionist thinking and plain glossing-over of important caveats and assumptions in the applied theories.
Re:I Was Just Told “You would not have made it through the w... by asmithmd1 on Monday January 30, 2012 @10:54PM (#3531744)
Really? My town legislated a fire department into existence. Now we have "universal" fire protection for the town with no waiting.
Re:I Was Just Told “You would not have made it through the w... by pyre on Tuesday January 31, 2012 @02:08AM (#3532219)
You and your socialist agenda is destroying this country! Take your 'universal fire protection' and go back to the Soviet Union! </sarcasm>
Re:I Was Just Told “You would not have made it through the w... by wisty on Monday January 30, 2012 @09:22PM (#3531513)
If healthcare is an inelastic resource, the private sector won't make any more if you throw more money at it, and will just re-allocate it to those who can pay the most.
Re:I Was Just Told “You would not have made it through the w... by spindritf on Monday January 30, 2012 @09:56PM (#3531606)
Scarce doesn't mean inelastic and health care -- especially basic one including antibiotics, vaccines, etc. -- is not inelastic, you can get more, as much as you like, really, if you divert resources from other pursuits.
Re:I Was Just Told “You would not have made it through the w... by aiscott on Tuesday January 31, 2012 @01:42AM (#3532158)
Doctors are what I had in mind.
Re:I Was Just Told “You would not have made it through the w... by derleth on Tuesday January 31, 2012 @02:01AM (#3532199)
The only way in which you're correct is that the supply of skilled practitioners (doctors, nurses, etc.) may well be inelastic, in that only so many of them will be born in a given timeframe and it requires a certain length of time to take a potentially good practitioner all the way up to actually being a good practitioner.