News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:And yet It Understands by ben_w on Sunday March 26, 2023 @07:17AM (#35313205)
Interesting insight.

For me, the (tree) analogy is that of an illusion of progress: while the treetop is closer than the ground, there is no tree that can ever be tall enough to get the rest of the way.

So, it isn't supposed to be used to say "you can't do it at all", just "you can't do it like that".

But metaphors get mixed as soon as they leave the bottle of text and enter the cocktail shaker of other people's minds, so I am unshocked by the usage you are criticising here.

Re:And yet It Understands by glenstein on Sunday March 26, 2023 @07:48AM (#35313463)
>So, it isn't supposed to be used to say "you can't do it at all", just "you can't do it like that".

And I'm of two minds on this, because I find that to be a respectable position, and in fact, for this reason, I hope you show up to continue debates on this because your voice would be helpful and counteracting what I believe is the less reasonable position. Depending on how long you've been following debates on the topic, which have raged from essentially the 1950s through now, I would guesstimate that "you literally can never get to the moon" has at least at times enjoyed dominance as the majority position, and when not the majority position, is at least credited as being a respectable one.

And even in this dressed up reasonable version, it still feels wrong to me in an important way: if you did have a tree that was 328,900 miles tall, you could reach the Moon. There are so many opportunities along the way to mentally short circuit, and slip into practical considerations and lose sight of the principle. Of course no such tree exists, but it has critically illustrated that the entirety of the space from here to there is in principle traversable, and it's the insight into this principle that ultimately will get us from here to there.

It does mean you need to shift your focus of research from arborism to jet propulsion, and that is the important point made by your version of this argument. But it amounts to joining the 'arborists' in championing the possibility of getting there rather than being a skeptic of the possibility, and I feel like most people making this point imagine themselves to be taking the sides of the skeptic.

Re:And yet It Understands by PoignardAzur on Sunday March 26, 2023 @08:14AM (#35313642)
I think if I had to pick a strawman expression to thoroughly defeat, it would be something like "You can't go to the moon by shooting a very big canon".

Because on the one hand, yeah, no explosion-based canon is going to get you to the moon; there's just no way to give a payload enough initial momentum to escape the earth's gravity well without killing any humans in that payload.

On the other hand, once you have canons, Newtonian physics, and an understanding that the moon is a very distant rock and not, like, a spirit god or something, then you have enough information to realize that going to the moon is only a matter of time and enough iterative improvements on those canons. It doesn't require inventing a completely novel technology like portals or teleporters or whatever. (Though it requires a ton of improvements in material science, engineering, computing, etc.)

And I think it's meaningful that From the Earth to the Moon was Jules Vernes' third book, and A trip to the Moon the first science-fiction movie even made. People could see the writing on the wall.

It's harder to make any predictions about AGI, because intelligence is a much fuzzier target than "reaching escape velocity". But it feels like neural networks are closer to the canon than to the pile of chairs: a basic concept that might not be capable of reaching general intelligence, but is only one or two steps removed from one that will reach it given enough engineering and money;