News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:And yet It Understands by zetalyrae on Sunday March 26, 2023 @07:11AM (#35313170)
On an abstract level, it's obvious that intelligent design, symbolic representations etc. aren't needed to build a mind, because we _evolved_ and evolution is a blind optimizer.

But concretely, all the machine learning approaches had many obvious limitations (the volume of data, lack of generalization) until they suddenly didn't, and past a certain scale features of intelligence began to emerge.

Re:And yet It Understands by foldr on Sunday March 26, 2023 @07:18AM (#35313215)
>On an abstract level, it's obvious that intelligent design, symbolic representations etc. aren't needed to build a mind, because we _evolved_ and evolution is a blind optimizer.

This is playing pretty fast and loose. First of all, I wouldn't lump intelligent design together with the claim that symbolic representations are necessary to account for certain features of human intelligence (such as the classic Fodorian triad of compositionality, systematicity and productivity).

Second, I just don't think the logic of your sentence works. Why does it make any more sense than the following?

"It's obvious that fingers aren't needed to build a hand, because we _evolved_ and evolution is a blind optimizer."

Maybe you can build a functional equivalent of a hand without giving it any fingers. But the mere fact that we evolved doesn't tell us anything about whether or not that is possible.

Re:And yet It Understands by ElFitz on Sunday March 26, 2023 @07:33AM (#35313339)
I might be wrong but I think it’s more of a "It’s obvious you don’t need to have fingers to build a hand that has fingers" than building a fingerless functional equivalent to a hand.
Re:And yet It Understands by zetalyrae on Sunday March 26, 2023 @07:24AM (#35313267)
The point is that at no point in evolutionary history did a cognitive scientist sit down and write a bunch of S-expression GOFAI rules for human cognition.
Re:And yet It Understands by foldr on Sunday March 26, 2023 @07:26AM (#35313287)
Of course not, but who is claiming that this happened? I'm not sure I can think of even single person who is both (i) an intelligent design advocate and (ii) explicitly committed to a symbolic model of human cognitive capacities. This seems like a straw man. You might as well say that at no point in evolutionary history did an embryologist ever write down a plan for the eight developmental stages of a human fetus.
Re:And yet It Understands by _dain_ on Sunday March 26, 2023 @07:50AM (#35313474)
the "intelligent design advocates" doesn't refer to creationists in this context, it refers to GOFAI people.