Also, Venturebeat is far from the worst offender. At least they (ostensibly) have reporters.
I'm not going to say that her having written a decent article a year ago confers a ton of respectability on VentureBeat but it's not all bad.
On those occasions where Venturebeat gets it right, someone will inevitably blog it. The blog posts won't get banned. People will find out about the article. Meanwhile, Venturebeat has that much less incentive to directly troll HN.
I have zero illusions that Venturebeat is going to get banned. The incentives are wrong for Paul Graham. Venturebeat writes more positive stuff about YC companies than negative stuff. But if Graham is serious about Venturebeat trolling the site --- which it clearly does, all the time --- he shouldn't be choosy about pushing back on it.
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3167050
How about instead of us unproductively arguing about this, you make your point by telling us about some of the popular sites you have banned for baiting HN. I'd be particularly interested in the existence proof of any site that regularly writes positive things about startups that you've squelched.
That'll give us an idea of what the standard is.
Edit: I accidentally wrote that first sentence more combatively than I meant to.
Anything that good hackers would find interesting. That includes more than hacking and startups. If you had to reduce it to a sentence, the answer might be: anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity.
Curebit's follies definitely interest hackers in two ways:
- How far is too far when 'Keeping It Lean'?
- How important is design to startups?
Off-Topic: ... If they'd cover it on TV news, it's probably off-topic.
Can't really prove a negative here, but this is certainly the sort of inside baseball that belongs on a startup-focused medium and not on broadcast television.
Edit:
It could be that this is the ballyhooed YC naughtiness [2] at work:
Though the most successful founders are usually good people, they tend to have a piratical gleam in their eye. They're not Goody Two-Shoes type good. Morally, they care about getting the big questions right, but not about observing proprieties. That's why I'd use the word naughty rather than evil. They delight in breaking rules, but not rules that matter. This quality may be redundant though; it may be implied by imagination.
The article here does not try to tackle either of those questions.
The fact is that this is an incredibly pertinent tale for startups, especially those launched by these high-profile programmes where the spotlight will be on from day one, and the lessons it brings, along with the negative publicity is extremely important.
Sure, you can bury the story and say that it's the fault of the community (that YC has fostered itself, organically) for taking an interest in a story, that whilst presented as fluff, contains (as far as we can tell from the comments made by all parties) very solid facts that compound those in a current thread of news, but hey, it'll blow over soon.
As you sow so you shall reap, and all that.
People already think HN is a YC propaganda machine, which long time users know isn't true, and this kind of thing just fuels the conspiracy theories.
That said the "tech" relevance of the story isn't that big & I feel bad for Curebit, I read DHH 's post on twitter about it yesterday & although they are making incredible stupid mistakes, one public flame is enough, they're also just trying to start a company.
I usually err on the side of not killing stories criticizing startups we'd funded, but if this was about a startup we didn't fund I'd kill it in a second. (Though of course I wouldn't have to, because few would upvote such a story, which means no journalist would bother writing it.) So I'm going to bury it. I'd rather seem like I'm censoring bad news about startups we funded than let Venturebeat fill HN with crap like this.