News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Protobuffers Are Wrong (2018) by hot_gril on Thursday March 23, 2023 @07:27PM (#35282978)
Yeah, I stopped reading at "by far, the biggest problem with protobuffers is their terrible type-system" for similar reasons. What did the author want, ASN.1? Cause that gives you a full type system, except that's not what I want.

Edit: kentonv's rebuttal says this too. "This article appears to be written by a programming language design theorist who, unfortunately, does not understand (or, perhaps, does not value) practical software engineering." And when my angry hat is on, this is also how I would generalize programming language design theorists.

Re:Protobuffers Are Wrong (2018) by mianos on Thursday March 23, 2023 @08:22PM (#35283429)
Funny you should mention ASN.1. Protobuffers is Really just a toy ASN.1 written by some guys who just solved the problem at hand instead of looking further afar. It's great for what it is. Many of us have written something similar.

It's not a pro level system designed by a serious telecom team.

Re:Protobuffers Are Wrong (2018) by hot_gril on Thursday March 23, 2023 @08:36PM (#35283551)
I worked on LTE stuff during a research/engineering position. It was just 1 year and not my life's work, but I had to deeply understand ASN.1 for it. I didn't like ASN.1 even for its intended use case. That big type system was far more complex than necessary for the protocols I was dealing with (surrounding the EPC mainly). It was more optimized in other ways, sacrificing some flexibility in favor of performance because the ends are expected to be more coordinated, but that's separate.