Re:Stanford’s War Against Its Own Students
by tptacek on Thursday March 23, 2023 @05:45PM
(#35281720)
I get that there are process concerns here (and that people think the rules Stanford is enforcing are dumb). But the stakes seem very low: we're talking about procedural due process protecting the rights of fraternities to host parties with alcohol.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Stanford’s War Against Its Own Students
by bgentry on Thursday March 23, 2023 @05:47PM
(#35281740)
But the stakes seem very low: we're talking about procedural due process protecting the rights of fraternities to host parties with alcohol.
No? The quote is in reference to a lawyer defending students accused of cheating on an exam and facing an administrative process with no presumption of innocence or right to a proper defense. A process which could permanently destroy their college education and career prospects.
Re:Stanford’s War Against Its Own Students
by tptacek on Thursday March 23, 2023 @06:02PM
(#35281900)
Here we're talking about a case where students were, in 2012, accused of cheating on a bio test, and not found guilty. Meanwhile: cheating is absolutely rampant --- and has presumably only gotten much, much worse since 2012.
Re:Stanford’s War Against Its Own Students
by mkoubaa on Thursday March 23, 2023 @07:43PM
(#35283121)
I've seen people cheat first hand dozens of times and know that a jury would find them not guilty. Legal standards are very high
The standards should be high in any situation where you can significantly harm a person's life trajectory, even if not in a criminal court. Getting kicked out of Stanford for cheating could definitely derail a person's life.
The overwhelming majority of high-achieving students can't get in to Stanford to begin with, so it's hard for me to understand how being asked to leave Stanford could be ruinous.
Re:Stanford’s War Against Its Own Students
by Rebelgecko on Friday March 24, 2023 @01:11AM
(#35285313)
People get expelled for cheating and it can impact the rest of their lives