News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Will Transformers Transform? by ay on Thursday March 23, 2023 @07:58AM (#35273349)
I tried the example about the table not fitting into the car using GPT4. Not only it answered it correctly, but it actively (but politely) argued with me when I tried to imply a different target for “it”:

https://mobile.twitter.com/ayourtch/status/16388720452817879...

(Edit: it did of course end up in a nonsense, so one can argue the point of not having the model of the world still stands; there is an “edge of bullshit”, but it seems to be moving further with each update)

At this point the arguments about about LLMs need to be tagged, which exact version they are talking about. (Probably most are talking about GPT3.5)

My (small) experience playing with both indicates there is a significant gap between the two.

Re:What Will Transformers Transform? by sparsevector on Thursday March 23, 2023 @08:33AM (#35273717)
I also tried this out and the balloon example as well.

User: Barbara, Mary, and Harry had red balloons. Ted had a blue balloon. Sam also had a red balloon. How many children have red balloons?

ChatGPT (GPT-4): Barbara, Mary, Harry, and Sam each had a red balloon. That means there are 4 children with red balloons.

User: What about Ted?

ChatGPT (GPT-4): Ted had a blue balloon, not a red one. So, he is not counted among the children with red balloons. Therefore, the total number of children with red balloons remains 4.

User: Why do you think I asked my original question?

ChatGPT (GPT-4): It seems that you asked your original question to test my ability to understand and process information provided in a text. You wanted to see if I could correctly identify and count the number of children with red balloons based on the details given.

User: Can you explain what mistakes a simpler model may have made on this question?

ChatGPT (GPT-4): A simpler language model may have made the following mistakes when answering your original question: ...

I like trying these sort of puzzles and "gotcha" prompts and I've found GPT-3.5 and lower versions are indeed not hard to confuse, but it's much harder to find simple examples that confuse GPT-4. Often times GPT-4 will even be able to explain the puzzle and why it's interesting. I think this is part of why GPT-4 feels qualitatively different. I understand (roughly) how transformers work, but GPT-4 does seem to have some emergent ability to reason, at least in the sense of making short chains of logical inferences, and this does seem to inform text completions not just on these sort of puzzles. That said I do think there's real danger of overconfidence and over reliance.

Re:What Will Transformers Transform? by imjonse on Thursday March 23, 2023 @09:17AM (#35274290)
I thought the gotcha was that nowhere was it stated which of them are actually children.
Re:What Will Transformers Transform? by kzrdude on Thursday March 23, 2023 @11:44AM (#35276571)
How it just takes these implicit assumptions in stride makes me worry that in the future these chatbots will be fine with assumptions and me - human - has a too square brain to go on without definitions. :)
Re:What Will Transformers Transform? by usaar333 on Thursday March 23, 2023 @10:24AM (#35275295)
Agreed GPT4 is better, but there's still simple world modeling issues:

> I have a chair in front of the TV and one in front of the computer. I put a watch under the chair in front of the TV. I swap the chairs. Where is the watch?

> After swapping the chairs, the watch is now under the chair that is in front of the computer.

Re:What Will Transformers Transform? by kenjackson on Thursday March 23, 2023 @10:55AM (#35275761)
I just tried it and it says it’s under the chair in front of the computer. I used the Bing model.
Re:What Will Transformers Transform? by letmevoteplease on Thursday March 23, 2023 @10:55AM (#35275775)
I asked GPT 4 (Bing) your question, but added "(Please give a plausible explanation for why this question could be answered either way.)"

> This question could be answered either way depending on how you interpret the phrase “under the chair”. If you mean under the chair as in attached to the bottom of the chair, then the watch would move with the chair when you swap them. In that case, the watch would be in front of the computer. However, if you mean under the chair as in on the floor below the chair, then the watch would stay on the same spot when you swap the chairs. In that case, the watch would be in front of the TV. So, it depends on what you mean by “under”.

Re:What Will Transformers Transform? by usaar333 on Thursday March 23, 2023 @11:48AM (#35276629)
Yes, but that's a huge hint. GPT4 naively doesn't understand this.

Question:

> I have a chair in front of the TV and one in front of the computer. I put a watch under the chair in front of the TV. I swap the chairs. Where is the watch?

> Work out step by step. Is this question ambiguous?

Answer:

This question is not ambiguous, but let's break it down step by step to understand the situation and find the location of the watch.

You have a chair in front of the TV (Chair A) and one in front of the computer (Chair B). You put a watch under Chair A (the one in front of the TV). You swap the chairs, meaning Chair A is now in front of the computer and Chair B is in front of the TV. After swapping the chairs, the watch remains under Chair A. Since Chair A is now in front of the computer, the watch is under the chair in front of the computer.

Re:What Will Transformers Transform? by blueorange8 on Thursday March 23, 2023 @12:42PM (#35277444)
Ya gpt-4 is still confused: (it's interesting cause it does realize the watch doesn't move but still gets it wrong)

Model: GPT-4

I have a chair in front of the TV and one in front of the computer. I put a watch under the chair in front of the TV. I swap the chairs. Where is the watch?

Work out step by step. Also define "under the chair". Is the question ambiguous?

Step 1: A chair with a watch under it is in front of the TV. Step 2: Another chair is in front of the computer. Step 3: The chairs are swapped.

To clarify the term "under the chair," let's define it as a watch placed beneath the chair, such that the chair is directly above the watch.

Now let's analyze the situation after swapping the chairs.

After Step 3:

The chair that was initially in front of the TV (with the watch under it) is now in front of the computer. The chair that was initially in front of the computer is now in front of the TV. As the question is about the location of the watch, it is important to note that the watch was not mentioned to be moved along with the chair. Therefore, the watch remains in its original position, which is under the chair that was initially in front of the TV.

The question could be considered ambiguous if one assumes that the watch was also moved along with the chair. However, since the watch's movement was not explicitly mentioned, it is reasonable to assume that the watch remained in its original position during the chair swap.

So, the watch is still under the chair that was initially in front of the TV, which is now in front of the computer.

Re:What Will Transformers Transform? by zootreeves on Thursday March 23, 2023 @10:57AM (#35275815)
Question isn't clear if the watch is stuck to the bottom of the chair.
Re:What Will Transformers Transform? by blueorange8 on Thursday March 23, 2023 @01:17PM (#35278008)
If I ask it like this, if gets it right:

I have a chair in front of the TV and one in front of the computer. I placed a watch on the floor beneath the chair in front of the TV. Then, I swapped the positions of the chairs. Where is the watch now?

After swapping the positions of the chairs, the watch is now on the floor beneath the chair that was initially in front of the computer, since that chair is now in front of the TV.

Re:What Will Transformers Transform? by layer8 on Thursday March 23, 2023 @04:00PM (#35280486)
This is not a competition in getting it to answer right, though. It’s that the instances where it answers wrong demonstrate its lack of inner mental model of what it is supposedly reasoning about, as well as a lack of meta-awareness. I think we tend to underestimate what mere linguistic correlation is capable of producing, and are too quick to attribute intelligent reasoning and an inner mental model to it.
Re:What Will Transformers Transform? by yorwba on Thursday March 23, 2023 @09:31AM (#35274496)
The answering style matches the usual presentation of a Winograd schema, which is a bit of a problem when you actually want to test its general reasoning ability, because it could be that someone already posted your go-to test question and the answer on the internet and the model was trained on that.

Maybe we need to start obfuscating this stuff

  import base64;import hashlib;f=lambda s:bytes(k^v for k,v in zip(hashlib.shake_256(b'wOmGLuIVp70').digest(len(s)),s));print(f(base64.decodebytes(b'Iq6VQOBRifQwwwO6gluzzWEnGIICFKKFwM1oMWmBsTrIhMj5AseeNmNUwtEZkthcz8m8v8qKmVIx7nEjPOsqOUimKaTIJ8OKk2STdo/SRZGLAOsBSmgGaNTYEgT3KaayJWmGVf7K/UN06VyosEHfyFZlsS+PHDS6B3bN94qrzdnOA9f12FwWuaTPNJhLGcXFX7r5H8mtWyt9uWq6n5AItEcRXId04ssR8jfvNray2fwFIh5qPHTdQvZ9ogKLJ4Y+nAro7ecRSXXgskAj5EBmo2YobRkfE26er/Tj9DZHNx81N64ujWvN8jiS7aNcYs/oaEyN0oqnZvia9qocrv6CfBr+wGGSG1oxk5mbhAgkQhfuyR6c8MVKNFKp8HFo6SR7auju8vLnYjcObcII88vRbbua/jQmakiWwmS68Y1e1Gqmqg==')).decode())
to avoid burning test questions. (GPT-3.5 gave the answer I expected on the 4th try, didn't test with GPT-4.)
Re:What Will Transformers Transform? by jxy on Thursday March 23, 2023 @12:35PM (#35277348)
GPT-4 answered correctly and explained the chemical reaction.
Re:What Will Transformers Transform? by yorwba on Thursday March 23, 2023 @02:00PM (#35278766)
That's good to hear.
Re:What Will Transformers Transform? by thefreeman on Thursday March 23, 2023 @09:44AM (#35274684)
The biggest takeaway from the article for me was GPT 4 has 100 trillion parameters, 500x more then GPT 3. that type of exponential scaling is going to hit an upper bound really quickly. So when you say it “moves further with each update” you should realize that the improvements are coming from throwing massively more scale at the problem and not some underlying improvement in the technique, and also balance the amount of improvement with the scale itself.

obviously gpt-4 is nowhere near 500x better than gpt-3. let’s say it’s 20% better (very generous imo). can they realistically 500x the model again? and if so, is that going to be worth an additional 4% gain to the original model quality? numbers are completely made up and math is probably wrong but i think i’m hopefully making my point, that diminishing returns will quickly become a blocker with this type of scaling.

Re:What Will Transformers Transform? by carbocation on Thursday March 23, 2023 @09:50AM (#35274786)
I would hesitate to assume that is true. The 100 trillion param number has not been confirmed by anyone who could know if it’s true.
Re:What Will Transformers Transform? by og_kalu on Thursday March 23, 2023 @09:51AM (#35274792)
Gpt-4 doesn't have 100 trillion parameters. It's not much larger than 3. It just has a lot more data according to Altman.
Re:What Will Transformers Transform? by qualudeheart on Thursday March 23, 2023 @09:57AM (#35274876)
Altman himself has said it doesn’t have 100T parameters. It has more data in line with the Chinchilla laws.
Re:What Will Transformers Transform? by blueorange8 on Thursday March 23, 2023 @01:20PM (#35278073)
I don't believe they spent 7 months just "making gpt-4 safer" - I think they spent a very long time doing human reinforcement learning to make it better and now hope to speed that process up the next time using gpt-4 itself as the reinforcement.
Re:What Will Transformers Transform? by r0uv3n on Friday March 24, 2023 @04:12AM (#35286369)
AFAIK the paper mentioned that RLHF mostly decreased its capabilities. It seems more likely to me that just longer normal training was one of the main reason for the increased capabilities.
Re:What Will Transformers Transform? by cinntaile on Thursday March 23, 2023 @09:50AM (#35274779)
We shouldn't forget that at the same time effort is being spent to achieve the same results with a lot fewer parameters.
Re:What Will Transformers Transform? by HarHarVeryFunny on Thursday March 23, 2023 @03:23PM (#35279997)
I tried the car-table example too (via Bing), using the exact same wording, and got a totally different confused reply, so it must think the two parsings of the sentence are closely probable (and isn't deterred by the semantics).

I tried it with Bard too, which also thought the table was too small to fit in the car, and doubled down on this when pressed by explaining how the table might be too narrow or deep or heavy(!) to fit in the car.

I was a bit surprised to see GPT-4 get this wrong, even it it's only doing so some of the time (sampling temperature randomness?).

Re:What Will Transformers Transform? by HarHarVeryFunny on Thursday March 23, 2023 @03:31PM (#35280094)
Just tried again with GPT-4 (exactly as before), and reply this time was simply "The table didn’t fit in the car because it was too big. Do you have any other questions?".

Bing/GPT bolded the words "too big".

But as I said before, the fact that it sometimes gets it wrong must mean it doesn't see one parsing as much to be favored over the other, which is surprising given how competent it generally is.