Source: currently looking into extended stay Airbnb for family member with no credit history
There's no way in hell this was some place that pleasant white upper class families were staying on vacation or something. The people that rented it were happy to have market penetration to people who weren't in the neighborhood to cause problems, and most of the "tenants" were working class people who had one foot in the hood and one foot working their way up in legitimate jobs closer to the loop.
AirBnB IS the new halfway house.
A platform to bring people with extra rooms together with those looking for a place
That just sounds like someone that is salty because they don't own a rental property so the profits are going to someone else.
My family has been renting single family large home in North Carolina for a week every year for decades. Short term rentals have always been around, technology/AirBNB promoted the existence of them to wider audience. That demand existed before the Airbnb founders were born. So get rid of Airbnb and the demand for that goes away? I don't think so.
Housing is a tough problem in the same way the medical care is a tough problem. There are economics at play and individuals finances. I don't have a good solution but have trouble accepting blanket statements that sort of hand wavily ignore real market demand for things.
These are not hard nor tough problems. Every industrial nation and many developing nations have the medical care issue solved. The US ignores solutions to the medical care issue due to our corrupt political system. Remove Legal Bribery from the political system and the US would implement a number of solutions that would solve about 80% of the medical care issues.
Landlords do not need to be private individuals :)
> but the idea of owning investments isn't going to dissolve any time soon and physical assets (homes) are one investment vehicle.
Singapore, a country that scores higher in the Capitalism Index than the US, has no private landlords and all land is goverment owned. You buy your house from the goverment for non market rates, and if you wanna sell it or move elsewhere, you sell it for the price at that point.
It is no longer an investment, and people have more space, smaller rents and an easier way to go through the housing ladder (from starter home -> family home -> retirement home) than in almost any US metro.
Another alternative is Vienna. The Austrian capital has ton of communally owned houses. This means everyone in the block, owns the whole block, therefore the prices are not market prices but fair prices. Despite this houses representing only 40% of the total market, by having a non market offering of housing prices, this cools down market prices and they have some of the most affordable private owned houses in European capitals.
A third alternative is UK 1950's scheme of council housing. A percentage of every new build is done by the goverment and they allocate those houses with reduced rents to its owners. The differece with the modern "social housing" is that is not a block in the ghetto for poor people, but a mixture of houses for everyone in the council to apply. For example The Barbican, a now iconic buulding, was built by the council for high skill workers, lawyers, CEOs etc (with an average rent that would be too high for minimum wage renters). Despite this target audience, they froze rent for 5 years to help families grow and settle into those homes.
There are a million better ways to supply housing than private landlords and letting companies buy entire blocks as investment vehicles.
John Paul Stevens on Prop 13[1]:
In comments from the bench, Blackmun called California’s tax system “distasteful, unwise and not likely to be copied by others.”
Justice John Paul Stevens, the lone dissenter, called the state’s longtime homeowners “squires” who voted themselves “a tremendous windfall” at the expense of young people and new residents.
“Simply put,” he said, “those who invested in California real estate in the 1970s are among the most fortunate capitalists in the world.”
[1] https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1992-06-19-mn-704-st...
There will always be the need for landlords in some circumstances. Not everyone wants to own a home and sometimes life dictates the need for flexibility. Where do you draw the line? I'm not sure what to think of it, but the idea of owning investments isn't going to dissolve any time soon and physical assets (homes) are one investment vehicle.
Coming from a person who has rented for a long time, currently owns one home and does not rent.