News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Construction Projects Always Go over Budget by colineartheta on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @10:50PM (#35256184)
Have you ever worked on the construction of a skyscraper?

I only ask, because, well, that was my question originally, and, well, because your question does nothing to answer that question.

So, have you? Or are you just another online bystander?

Re:Why Construction Projects Always Go over Budget by skippyboxedhero on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @11:03PM (#35256284)
Let's get this straight: you haven't worked on the construction of a skyscraper, but you just go around shutting down arguments you don't like (made from no knowledge) by asking people if they worked on it personally...I don't think you have thought this through.

And the point was: you don't need to have worked on a skyscraper. The reason why it can be done quicker and cheaper is because that is already happening. It is like someone telling you the sun exists, you looking up in the sky and seeing it, and then saying "have you ever worked on the sun? are you a physicist? how do you know the sun exists if you aren't?"...the most lame form of third-party internet gatekeeping out there. Inferring that only very reasoned, intelligent arguments can convince you...whilst making a completely unreasoned, unthoughtful point that doesn't even attempt to engage...classic.

Re:Why Construction Projects Always Go over Budget by jacoblambda on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @11:20PM (#35256399)
> Let's get this straight: you haven't worked on the construction of a skyscraper, but you just go around shutting down arguments you don't like

Where do they say that?

> The reason why it can be done quicker and cheaper is because that is already happening

Have we seen any evidence that the construction is just as consistent & reliable long term or that the speed isn't at the cost of the worker (safety or benefits)?

Re:Why Construction Projects Always Go over Budget by skippyboxedhero on Wednesday March 22, 2023 @04:44PM (#35266824)
I will ask you a question: you go into the doctor, he says you need surgery immediately, you ask why, and your doctor asks what your medical qualifications are...does this seem like something a doctor would do?

Have we seen any evidence that this isn't the case? And the inherent assumption in your argument is that preserving "the worker" (I am not sure what this means) is a fair price to pay for hundreds of billions in graft every year...okay, why? The point of comment is to demonstrate that the purpose of building infrastructure is not to employ consultants, but to build buildings...the false narrative about "the worker" is exactly why several hundred consultants with Ivy League degrees are taking home $1k/hour for no-show consultancy jobs...thank God "the worker" is okay though.

Re:Why Construction Projects Always Go over Budget by colineartheta on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @11:48PM (#35256580)
For the record, yeah, I’ve worked on putting up multiple skyscrapers. From the on-site work (physically speaking: I was a field surveyor laying out grid lines and offsets for the other trades), and off-site (as a construction project manager).
Re:Why Construction Projects Always Go over Budget by wincy on Wednesday March 22, 2023 @01:14AM (#35257093)
Hey that’s great to see a construction manager on here. I write software specifically for our superintendents and construction managers and foremen at some of the mega projects my big construction company works on (I’m sure you’d recognize the name if you’ve worked in the industry).

I find it really rewarding work because with software I often feel detached from the work I do. I’m going to get to go on site and see something getting built soon and I’m excited!