News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rolling Stone left out the reason why FBI raided journali... by derefr on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @03:44PM (#35251497)
> The sources are trustworthy or not

Read that quote carefully — there's two layers to it.

The source is "familiar with the matter" — the journalist trusts what they have to say.

What the source says, though, is that federal agents allegedly found classified information. In other words, the source claims that the federal agents themselves are claiming this; but the source does not put any credence in this claim, and didn't want to communicate the claim in such a way that the journalist would put credence into it.

If the source actually believed the feds, there would be no need for the "allegedly" in the sentence; the "says" would do fine at making a use-mention distinction between the journalist's beliefs and a source's claims.

Re:Rolling Stone left out the reason why FBI raided journali... by avianlyric on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @04:25PM (#35252002)
The use of the word “allegedly” is standard practice for reputable new organisations reporting on an individual being charged, but not yet convicted.

A core tenet of the justice system is the idea that your innocence until proven guilty. Hence the use of the word “allegedly”, by default any claims made by the government shouldn’t be treated as proven, until they’ve proved them in a court of law.

To assume that a law enforcement official, or prosecutors charges are true before they’ve proven them in a court of law would be to ignore due process. To publish those charges as facts, would be libel.

Re:Rolling Stone left out the reason why FBI raided journali... by derefr on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @07:49PM (#35254535)
Everything you're saying would be true if it was the journalist themselves doing the alledging. But the journalist is quoting a source through paraphrase, and the source is doing the alledging.

It is not libel to say "An anonymous source said [libelous thing.]" Because there is no claim made through that statement that what the anonymous source is saying, is true. The only claim being made through that statement is that that claim is in fact what the source said. If the anonymous source wasn't anonymous, maybe they'd be guilty of libel. But the journalist isn't. They're just reporting on the libel someone else is committing.

Re:Rolling Stone left out the reason why FBI raided journali... by burkaman on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @03:52PM (#35251610)
Yes that's fine, and a great use of the word allegedly, but it's not fine to pick and choose which alleged allegations from the same source you include, and replace their unverified allegations with your own.

Source: Federal agents found classified documents and CSAM on his computer.

Rolling Stone: Federal agents allegedly found classified documents on his computer. The question looms on what grounds the feds would have had room to act on Meek. He appears to be on the wrong side of the national-security apparatus. Maybe they were retaliating for his legitimate reporting activities?