Re:Consider Phlebas Published by the Folio Society
by mr_toad on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @08:42PM
(#35255055)
It was literally a story about space pirates. You seem to be expecting Walden.
Re:Consider Phlebas Published by the Folio Society
by TheHappyOddish on Wednesday March 22, 2023 @04:34AM
(#35258336)
You seem to be doing what movie critics do to movies.
Does everything need to be a criticism, play on or comparative or something? Does everything need some deeper meaning?
It's a fun action sci-fi book. Do you question the motivations of Sam-I-Am in Green Eggs and Ham? Why does he insist so much? Where did this food come from? Does he have an ulterior motivation? Is this a reflection on 1970s conservatism in the UK and societies inability to adventure and explore?
I guess I just don't see where any extra juice is going to come from. Canticle for Leibowitz has a beautiful meditation on human nature. Diaspora shows several very non-arbitrary forms of life, discusses disobeying a person's expressly stated values to save their life, and touches on the consequences of immortality and immortality alone. In comparison, I struggle to see how Consider Phlebas is anything other than solid C-grade sci-fi.