Also, just because you can segment something into true/false, absolutely does not mean you have to look at each case equally. You either have or do not have cancer. That doesn't mean there's a 50% chance you have cancer.
Your matrix of course splits nicely with "ETs or no" and on the other hand is arbitrarily extendable in various dimensions. But in any case, just because yours has four entries shouldn't keep you from considering each option.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perverse_incentive#The_origina...
The recent behavior of the US government/military is not compatible with "no ETs anywhere". Confabulations to the contrary universally suffer from serious plotholes.
But as you say, people's assumptions prevent them from considering options without irrational bias.
If you admit, you cannot really know whether or not they are (much less give a reasonable estimate for likelihood), you have to look at both options equally.
Interestingly, given ET-visitation, just as posited by "UFOlogy" taking place since at least Roswell, fits remarkably well with observations mentioned here. At the very least, there doesn't seem to be any real contradiction?
The leaks you mentioned weren't instigated by "the government", by the way. Rather, some group of relative insiders did that.