News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Could UFOs be alien probes? A new 2023 Harvard study expl... by bumby on Monday March 20, 2023 @12:54PM (#35234583)
For anyone interested, the author (Avi Loeb) has a very accessible book titled "Extraterrestrial" that goes into the details of why the Oumuamua interplanetary object may be more likely to be a "space buoy" or light sail than a comet.
Re:Could UFOs be alien probes? A new 2023 Harvard study expl... by 7thaccount on Monday March 20, 2023 @01:11PM (#35234882)
I watched a video recently of a physicist criticizing his recent work. He is a Harvard professor, so obviously a smart guy, but there are things to think about here.

First of all, he's going on and on about the establishment and how they're not doing enough and so on. He was literally calling out Jill Tartar the famous SETI scientist that was the inspiration for the contact book/movie. It is a little weird to poop on someone who has spent their entire life begging congress for money to do more research looking for alien life. He sounded completely irrational during it and suggested they didn't want to do anything when SETI does everything they can with their very limited funding. He then tried making fun of her for not publishing as many papers when his publishing record is suspect due to the sheer number of papers he puts out. Someone pointed out that being an author on 7 papers a month is basically impossible. When other scientists started looking in more depth, they noticed that the papers were mostly all very rough sketches of water cooler ideas and not the kind of quality that would normally be acceptable in journals if you weren't already a Harvard physicist. Then, I find some of his statements to baffle me as they seem obviously immature. He's basically said that it has to be an alien probe as nothing else makes sense. Other scientists are just saying...well sure...it could be that, but it seems more likely that we just haven't figured out the non-alien cause yet.

I'd appreciate some feedback from an actual physicist on the matter.

Re:Could UFOs be alien probes? A new 2023 Harvard study expl... by Loquebantur on Monday March 20, 2023 @01:30PM (#35235269)
Taking "some video" on the internet featuring "some physicist"(?) as basis for anything is ill-advised.

Worse, you are actually engaging in character assassination here by repeating that nonsense.

Re:Could UFOs be alien probes? A new 2023 Harvard study expl... by 7thaccount on Monday March 20, 2023 @03:43PM (#35237487)
I watched his chat with SETI in full and it was unprofessional to say the least. I stand by that. Here's an article talking about it:

https://www.forbes.com/sites/startswithabang/2021/02/16/watc...

As to the part on the papers, I was open that it was just hearsay and asked for someone with better background to weigh in. Here's a physicist going into some depth on what I referred to:

https://youtu.be/aY985qzn7oI

Re:Could UFOs be alien probes? A new 2023 Harvard study expl... by stametseater on Monday March 20, 2023 @01:38PM (#35235413)
I haven't read that book yet, but if I understand correctly his reasoning for the "space buoy" hypothesis is that Oumuamua's velocity was quite close to the Local Standard of Rest. Is that accurate? At least, that's the reasoning he claims in his "Six Strange Facts About`Oumuamua" article: https://arxiv.org/abs/1811.08832

In his book, does he address the counterargument (https://arxiv.org/abs/1907.01910) that such a velocity is entirely in line with expected parameters, being within the predicted distribution of values for intestellar objects detected by asteroid surveys, which was published months before Oumuamua was even discovered (https://arxiv.org/abs/1702.02237) ?

Re:Could UFOs be alien probes? A new 2023 Harvard study expl... by bumby on Monday March 20, 2023 @02:02PM (#35235814)
He outlines a number of anomalies but one of the larger points is that it deviates from its expected trajectory, leading to the possibility it’s a light sail. But I don’t recall if he addresses any specific studies.

I didn’t get the impression that he’s married to the idea that it’s a buoy. My main takeaway from the book is that he wants the establishment to at least be open to the idea of it being a of extraterrestrial origin rather than immediately dismissing the idea. He outlines some of the perverse incentives in academia that prevents many from seriously considering that idea.

Re:Could UFOs be alien probes? A new 2023 Harvard study expl... by stametseater on Monday March 20, 2023 @04:52PM (#35238509)
If his book addresses the counterargument and dismisses it, fair enough. But if he doesn't address the counterargument at all, then I have to conclude that he is deliberately misleading his readers by selectively presenting only the evidence that supports his favored conclusions.

I haven't read the book yet so I don't know how or if he responded, but some sort of response is certainly warranted. He claimed these orbital parameters were "strange" but here is a paper published before the discovery of Oumuamua that says Oumuamua's parameters are mundane and expected. That's not the sort of counterargument that should be ignored.

Re:Could UFOs be alien probes? A new 2023 Harvard study expl... by bumby on Monday March 20, 2023 @05:07PM (#35238739)
Can you possibly link to those articles directly? I'm not really able to add much based on just the abstract.

My thoughts on the book was that he was not making hard claims, but that the anomalies, particularly the joint probability of such anomalies, should lead us to at least be open to the idea of ET origins. His issue seemed to be that the idea was being superficially dismissed and not allowing it to be discussed, particularly with younger scientists without it potentially damaging their career. My recollection was that he wasn't even saying it was probable, just not impossible, and gatekeeping around investigating that possibility is bad science.