It is important to understand, we don't help you to fall asleep. This isn't an insomnia device. We increase the efficiency of deep sleep specifically, and it is most effective on people who already have lower/less deep sleep.
> Nothing in the existing research suggests this to be the case
Was it considered?
However, I will say that there is now more than a decade of research into slow-wave enhancement, and multiple studies looking at safety, and efficacy.
If dependency is a concern, it's somewhat the opposite. We're stimulating a sleep function that naturally degrades as we age, and trying to get it to maintain it's power. So you naturally lose this ability.
Note: we can't create slow waves (yet) we can only increase what is already there.
In the same way brain kindling works for seizures, my guess is sleep is a learnable skill, and once the pathway is etched it sticks around.
There will be other discoveries in the future, who knows what we'll learn, but the current body of knowledge (and there is a decent amount of it) does not suggest a learned response to be the case.
Furthermore, the sleep we stimulate is deep sleep, which naturally degrades as we age, which perhaps suggests that it isn't a learned response, or else why would we see a reduction with age.
That's honestly a fascinating concept. How is it panning out so far? Do you control for participants having sleep apnea/UARS/other organic sleep pathology?
There is LOTS of areas to look into once we have revenue and are looking more long-term opportunities.
I say "get to market 'quickly'" as it is still neuroscience, and as I describe in the parent, neurotech/eeg is not an easy physical thing to solve, then you've got the AI to build which is understanding the brainwave, providing the stimulation, and then adjusting the stimulation to the individual based on the resulting change in brainwave state.
I'm not sure where you are getting your "few bits/second" number. EEG chips can sample thousands of times per second, and it would also depend on how many channels you are running, and what you're looking for.
So the example OpenBCI board I linked to is an 8 channel device with 8,000 samples per second and 24 bits per sample - so 15m bits/second.
Or perhaps I'm misunderstanding the question.
Although for your sleep application, you may only be working with delta/theta waves.
But you are also correct we are currently only interested in the lower bands, mostly delta/theta/alpha, potentially beta when looking at wakefulness. We're not currently doing anything in gamma.
The hardware is one of the easier parts to build for an EEG system. Along with this device, you could also buy a very similar device from https://openbci.com (about $1000 for 12 channel, $400 for 4 channel).
The challenge in letting "anyone connect their brain to a computer" is in the electrode design and comfort/weirdness of the device.
First you've just got the dry electrodes, which can be expensive, and in many designs (Muse S) wear over time, requiring replacement headbands.
Many devices try going for the through hair electrode design, which is challenging for people with lots of hair, or curly afros (like myself).
Once you've got your electrodes figured out, then you have to figure out how to keep them in place, comfortably, over an extended period of time.
Ok, so you've got that sorted, now get that into a form factor a person will be happy to wear.
We are starting to see in-ear EEG devices built into headphones like the Emotiv Mn8 (https://www.emotiv.com/workplace-wellness-safety-and-product...).
However, even in these locations the electrodes are going to be sensitive to movement. So great it you are sitting still at work, but what are you really trying to accomplish.
So that's all the bad news. The good news is that with the low cost and experimentation that is happening in this space, I suspect we are going to learn more about the brain in the next 10 years than we have in the last 50.
It is becoming easier to watch the brain and learn more about it's functioning.
Many people ask what the benefit of a BCI device is. Unlike fitness monitors, which are giving users data, I believe the near future of BCI is in neurofeedback.
We're seeing a bunch of development from different start-ups (a bunch in Sydney, AUS - so reach out if you're local) that are looking at neurofeedback for treatment of psychological disorders.
At https://soundmind.co, we're using neurofeedback during sleep to increase the efficiency of deep sleep.