Re:Google Kills Android Menu Button, Replaces It with Action...
by bane on Saturday January 28, 2012 @10:40AM
(#3522296)
On iOS at least I think the single button is just fine, even preferable, and certainly far easier to understand and more consistent.
I don't disagree that the right mouse button can take new users a while to come to grips with.
The trade off of course is that even in moderately complex tools, a single button can't provide all of the actions a user would likely want to do. In the Mac world this was historically resolved by burying functions under layers of unmemorable keyboard combinations...e.g. command+shift+t or some such or in menus in the menu bar.
So the question then becomes, who do you optimize your interface for? The new user that can barely understand the abstraction of moving a physical device that's loosely mapped to screen coordinates? Or the user that needs to get-stuff-done-and-after-all-won't-be-a-new-user-all-that-long.
I personally think this move away from the menu button in Android land is a mistake. I already have issues with it on my Tab. With the software button showing up all over the screen or not at all.
I don't disagree that the right mouse button can take new users a while to come to grips with.
The trade off of course is that even in moderately complex tools, a single button can't provide all of the actions a user would likely want to do. In the Mac world this was historically resolved by burying functions under layers of unmemorable keyboard combinations...e.g. command+shift+t or some such or in menus in the menu bar.
So the question then becomes, who do you optimize your interface for? The new user that can barely understand the abstraction of moving a physical device that's loosely mapped to screen coordinates? Or the user that needs to get-stuff-done-and-after-all-won't-be-a-new-user-all-that-long.
I personally think this move away from the menu button in Android land is a mistake. I already have issues with it on my Tab. With the software button showing up all over the screen or not at all.