[1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35165640 "Firefox 111.0 enabled Origin private file system access"
[2]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33374402 "SQLite in the browser with WASM/JS"
What do you mean by "the attempt"? There are at least three independent decoder implementations:
jxl-oxide (Rust): https://github.com/tirr-c/jxl-oxide
J40 (C): https://github.com/lifthrasiir/j40
jxlatte (Java): https://github.com/thebombzen/jxlatte
None of them is feature complete, but it's because each of them is a hobby, single-person project. You're making it sound like some billion-dollar company tried to implement JPEG XL and failed, because it's too complex or something.
However, it should be noted that those independent implementations, despite being hobby projects, helped to iron-out some minor issues in the standard.
>Then AVIF got in, because AV1 was already in.
AVIF uses its own container format that had to be implemented. Implementing AV1 does not give you AVIF support for free.
Which is why they're not considered implementations to meet this bar. You need multiple FULL implementations to ensure that it is actually FULLY viable, otherwise you risk taking on a potentially broken format that you can't remove.
> You're making it sound like some billion-dollar company tried to implement JPEG XL and failed, because it's too complex or something.
I doubt any big company actually tried (or tried very hard). Cost of implementation becomes a kind of implicit test here, because companies like things cheap.
> AVIF uses its own container format that had to be implemented. Implementing AV1 does not give you AVIF support for free.
It gives AVIF support for cheap due to code/algorithm re-use. Companies like things cheap, so that's a big selling point.
So if an individual unpaid volunteer spends their time doing a 2nd implementation, <bigco> might consider it for their browser. But they won't pay for a 2nd implementation with their own staff, even if they own a humongous chunk of the browser market (which comes with responsibilities) and even if it is a better algorithm.
Sounds about right.
We make incremental gains as a human race, not necessarily optimal ones.
It's cool that there's a Rust implementation in progress. If it works out, it will make it much easier for me to support JXL. I've been waiting to RIIR the j40 instead.
AVIF (HEIF) container format is MP4, which browsers already parse for video. There is a bit of extra work to extract image-specific data, but it's minor compared to AV1 implementation. AVIF even contains a completely redundant copy of key AV1 metadata (av1C) to spare implementations from parsing the AV1 payload.
The main thing you want to have though, is a standard that cannot be unilaterally changed in arbitrary ways by a single party. However flawed it may be, ISO does have a long history of standardization, and it has procedures in place to ensure that changes are scrutinized and can only be applied when approved by the national standardization bodies.
There has been enough 3rd party interest to create multiple AV1/AVIF implementations. JPEG-XL has its original team (doing great work), and then… commenters lamenting, but nobody else invested enough to actually to write the code.
Browsers' goal is not just to have every benchmark-winning format. They also need to minimize attack surface, risk of bug-compatibility (which is why one and only implementation is not sufficient), and watch out for long-term costs of code size, maintenance, and technical debt. New codecs can be added at any time, but can never be removed.
AV1 got in, because video really needed an answer to the looming threat of patented expensive H.265. There was a risk of repeating the pains of H.264 support, and this time without Cisco's licensing loophole. Then AVIF got in, because AV1 was already in. It's that simple.