If you’re going to take a loss by selling an asset prematurely, it is illiquid. Otherwise you’d have to say things like the houses people own are liquid because the person could sell it in a day if they were willing to do so for 80 cents on the dollar.
That is not the financial world’s definition of “liquid”
Things one can sell at fair value in a few mins are liquid, and things one has to sell slowly or take 80 cents on the dollar to get rid of it fast (like a house in your example) are illiquid. It's a function of buyers and process, not my accounting treatment or tax treatment or whatever other treatment might make me not like the idea of selling right now.
What's next? The FX markets aren't liquid because I don't feel like realizing a gain from a tax perspective?
>> That is not the financial world’s definition of “liquid”
Yeah, it is, to us in the financial world.
>Yeah, it is, to us in the financial world.
I get the feeling we're talking around each other, your response indicates that we (probably) agree, and I'll assume it was my own communication failure, so I won't otherwise remark on this snarky & somewhat inaccurate (in its implications) comment.
The comment you were replying to said "quickly and at fair value".