Re:Linux maintainer rejects patches from sanctioned Russian ...
by pphysch on Thursday March 16, 2023 @03:13PM
(#35186847)
A professional reply would start like: "Thank you for your contributions. Unfortunately, due to uncertainty surrounding sanctions associated with your organization, we cannot accept your patches (...)".
This is not that.
The key is that the onus is clearly on the sanctions themselves, not the uncomfortable feelings of a mysterious "we".
Re:Linux maintainer rejects patches from sanctioned Russian ...
by anonymouskimmer on Friday March 17, 2023 @12:19AM
(#35193068)
Ritual phrasing does not make something professional. And the lack of ritual phrasing doesn't make it unprofessional.
Re:Linux maintainer rejects patches from sanctioned Russian ...
by pvaldes on Friday March 17, 2023 @04:32AM
(#35194605)
Is not even a professional relationship. They weren't hired by the company. Is a mutual aid one for achieving a common objective. Suspecting that your work will be most probably used to violate every single rule of war written and basically kill civils in mass is a good enough reason to decline to participate on this. No more justifications needed.
A much more professional response in this case would be: "go fuck yourselves".
Re:Linux maintainer rejects patches from sanctioned Russian ...
by pphysch on Friday March 17, 2023 @12:57PM
(#35199704)
Making something about personal feelings, when it is ostensibly not, is textbook unprofessionalism. How can you not see that?
Re:Linux maintainer rejects patches from sanctioned Russian ...
by anonymouskimmer on Saturday March 18, 2023 @03:09AM
(#35206876)
Because sociopaths are without expressive feeling, not professionals? If you've somehow learned, or have been taught, that professionalism means not emoting then you've been taught wrong IMO. Moderation in all things, including lack of emotion.
"I don't feel comfortable leaving pertinent information out of our regulatory filing, even if it's technically not against the law to do so."
Letting another person you are working with know that you are uncomfortable is the polite way to enforce personal boundaries in a professional, or personal, setting.
And Jakub is saying that "we don't feel comfortable". Discomfort can be for multiple reasons, not all of which may be known to the person (or given the "we", possibly people) feeling uncomfortable.
Asserting boundaries is rarely bullying. And I personally don't think this message, in the context we have here, rises past the level of asserting boundaries to bullying. Maintaining boundaries is a good thing that everyone has to learn to do, and have the fortitude to do. It's not easy.