Those speculating that the causation might lie in the other direction should at least bear in mind that this is a prospective cohort study (following a particular group of people over a long period of time). It found that – after controlling for income – people who worked longer hours were more likely to experience a subsequent major depressive episode.
Of course you might like to speculate that there is a hidden variable: perhaps some psychological factor that both predisposes people to work long hours and also increases their risk of depression. This research doesn’t rule out that possibility, as far as I can tell. To do that you would need to randomly assign people to the long-hours or short-hours condition and follow them for a period of time. I imagine it would be rather difficult to carry out a study of that sort.
Those speculating that the causation might lie in the other direction should at least bear in mind that this is a prospective cohort study (following a particular group of people over a long period of time). It found that – after controlling for income – people who worked longer hours were more likely to experience a subsequent major depressive episode.
Of course you might like to speculate that there is a hidden variable: perhaps some psychological factor that both predisposes people to work long hours and also increases their risk of depression. This research doesn’t rule out that possibility, as far as I can tell. To do that you would need to randomly assign people to the long-hours or short-hours condition and follow them for a period of time. I imagine it would be rather difficult to carry out a study of that sort.