News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:OpenAI Sold its Soul for $1B (2021) by lacker on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @03:21PM (#35173401)
The name "OpenAI" still really bugs me. But it seems likely that turning into a for-profit corporation was critical to OpenAI's subsequent success.

It let them raise enough money to pay for top-tier infrastructure. It also gave them access to stock options, to pay for recruiting a top-tier research and engineering team. I don't think we would have GPT-4 and the OpenAI API if they hadn't turned into a for-profit company.

And honestly, compare what OpenAI has done for AI research to the impact of any nonprofit. What nonprofit has done the most for AI research? Stanford? MIT? I'm not sure what the top AI achievement from any nonprofit is, in the modern era. It's like nonprofits can do a good job of kickstarting a field (AlexNet, early PyTorch), but once enough money and attention goes into it, they have to hand the baton to for-profit companies.

Re:OpenAI Sold its Soul for $1B (2021) by zitterbewegung on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @03:37PM (#35173606)
It would probably be too expensive now to rebrand themselves due to confusion. Honestly maybe they should have called themselves netai or alphaai
Re:OpenAI Sold its Soul for $1B (2021) by donkeydoug on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @03:58PM (#35173884)
idk, 'DarkMoneyAI' has a ring to it :)
Re:OpenAI Sold its Soul for $1B (2021) by pmarreck on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @03:31PM (#35173533)
It's not a "for-profit" (at least strictly, unless you are intentionally muddying the waters to support your argument). It's "capped-profit": https://techcrunch.com/2019/03/11/openai-shifts-from-nonprof...
Re:OpenAI Sold its Soul for $1B (2021) by blueboo on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @04:01PM (#35173931)
I wonder: What’s the cap, and how does it imply behaviour that differs from that of a for-profit?…
Re:OpenAI Sold its Soul for $1B (2021) by tangjurine on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @04:39PM (#35174398)
Capped at 100x profit from investment...
Re:OpenAI Sold its Soul for $1B (2021) by orra on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @04:43PM (#35174439)
The cap is so high as to be meaningless. It's for profit.
Re:OpenAI Sold its Soul for $1B (2021) by josephd79 on Thursday March 16, 2023 @01:01AM (#35178280)
So high you can see straight through the bs.
Re:OpenAI Sold its Soul for $1B (2021) by kulikalov on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @03:53PM (#35173823)
It seems like most fundamental researches were published by Google, not openai. Transformers architecture is also designed by Google…

These are superficial observations, so feel free to correct me if I’m wrong.

Also, they bought ai.com recently if that makes you feel better :) maybe they will drop the “open” part of their name soon.

Re:OpenAI Sold its Soul for $1B (2021) by lacker on Thursday March 16, 2023 @02:17AM (#35178771)
I don't disagree, Google has also made great AI advances and arguably more fundamental ones, with the transformer, Tensorflow, and Keras.

But Google is also a for-profit, so that fits in with my thesis here that when corporations start having an incentive to put a lot of money into an area, the cutting edge research starts to happen in for-profit companies, and nonprofits have trouble keeping up.

Re:OpenAI Sold its Soul for $1B (2021) by layer8 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @05:08PM (#35174732)
The problem with for-profit is that it informs priorities and incentives, usually not in the direction of societal benefit. That’s why the phrase “selling one’s soul” is being applied.
Re:OpenAI Sold its Soul for $1B (2021) by crazygringo on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @05:21PM (#35174888)
Well, Adam Smith argued that companies following selfish priorities and benefits is in the direction of societal benefit. (As long as all externalities like environmental pollution are priced in, but that isn't really relevant for OpenAI.)

It's really the bedrock of modern economics. Invisible hand of the market and all that.

Re:OpenAI Sold its Soul for $1B (2021) by Schroedingersat on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @07:01PM (#35175883)
Yes, the guy that hated landlords and considered rent seeking immoral would love the enclosure of the commons of all human knowledge and rent seeking on their imaginary IP rights.
Re:OpenAI Sold its Soul for $1B (2021) by DoughnutHole on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @08:17PM (#35176507)
Smith argued that this was in aggregate to the benefit of society, including competition between selfish businesses. He argued that monopolies are ultimately damaging to society.

The entity that first achieves real general AI has the potential to achieve a decisive strategic advantage that will allow it to shape the world in its image, free of competition. Traditional economics might not really apply anymore - the values that are built into the constructed intelligence will be paramount.

It won’t just all work out in the wash if we end up creating a superintelligence with values that are not to the benefit of humanity at-large.

Re:OpenAI Sold its Soul for $1B (2021) by Hasu on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:20PM (#35177745)
> The entity that first achieves real general AI has the potential to achieve a decisive strategic advantage that will allow it to shape the world in its image, free of competition.

The focus on "general AI" is so so so shortsighted. You don't need general AI. Really, you don't want it. It's far better to have tools that you can control and direct that are specialized in specific areas. Specialized AI tooling is a force multiplier that can be leveraged however you want, general AI is an employee that might disagree with your goals.

I'm not scared of a superintelligence, I'm scared of AI being O'Brien's boot stomping on the face of humanity forever, in service to the corporations that invent it first.

Re:OpenAI Sold its Soul for $1B (2021) by anon9219 on Thursday March 16, 2023 @01:02AM (#35178284)
Economics is literally a meme. Major corporations will go out of their way to harm society even if it reduces their profits.
Re:OpenAI Sold its Soul for $1B (2021) by selfhoster11 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @08:22PM (#35176551)
I'm seeing parallels to the concept of "attention" in AI. Perhaps we can build an attention function that isn't "make the most profit" and have a non-profit follow it.
Re:OpenAI Sold its Soul for $1B (2021) by xsuu on Thursday March 16, 2023 @10:20AM (#35182339)
Since the beginning, I've seen the "OpenAI" name as a giant Open-Washing. That works just like Green-Washing, and that works. I have no respect for this practice.