News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Generative AI is overrated, long live old-school AI by gautamdivgi on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:22PM (#35172519)
Isn’t most of the mathematics of AI old, as in really old?

Regression, both linear and logistic are from the mid 1800s to early 1900s. Neural networks, at least the basics are from around 1950.

What has really changed is the engineering, the data volume and the number of fields we can apply the mathematics to. The math itself (or what is the basis of AI) is really old.

Re:Generative AI is overrated, long live old-school AI by sterlind on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:37PM (#35172759)
backpropagation didn't get solved until the '80s, weirdly. before then people were using genetic algorithms to train neural networks.

and it was only in the last decade that the vanishing gradients problem was tamed.

my impression is that ML researchers were stumbling along in the mathematical dark, until they hit a combination (deep neural nets trained via stochastic gradient descent with ReLU activation) that worked like magic and ended the AI winter.

Re:Generative AI is overrated, long live old-school AI by version_five on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @03:26PM (#35173463)
Right, and the practice of neural networks has significantly overshot the mathematical theory. Most of the aspects we know work and result in good models have poorly understood theoretical underpinnings. The whole overparamiterized thing for example, or generalization generally. There's a lot that "just works" but we don't know why, thus the stumbling around and landing on stuff that works
Re:Generative AI is overrated, long live old-school AI by cma on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @08:41PM (#35176713)
> and it was only in the last decade that the vanishing gradients problem was tamed.

One of the big pieces was Schmidhuber's lab's highway nets, done ~30 years ago, but just didn't land until a more limited version was rediscovered.