News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Launch HN: Propify (YC W23) – Real Estate API Aggregator by ramesh31 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @01:02PM (#35171296)
Should probably clarify in the title that this is for property management, not real estate. MLS data is notoriously impossible to get without huge contracts, which is what made want to check this out.
Re:Launch HN: Propify (YC W23) – Real Estate API Aggregator by ismokedoinks on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @01:12PM (#35171490)
I misread it the same way--I've been praying for a good API to do some housing affordability data projects.
Re:Launch HN: Propify (YC W23) – Real Estate API Aggregator by imnotreallynew on Thursday March 16, 2023 @11:15AM (#35183034)
What sort of API? I’m working on another real estate project and were focusing on generic listings APIs. Would love to know your use case.
Re:Launch HN: Propify (YC W23) – Real Estate API Aggregator by ismokedoinks on Friday March 17, 2023 @03:57PM (#35202050)
My research is in urban planning so I mostly use city/state/federal data and occasionally data from court cases.

Most of that data is sparsely updated and I'm not clued in on many real estate APIs to track up-to-date trends in housing and prices so I would love to know more about what your work looks like!

Re:Launch HN: Propify (YC W23) – Real Estate API Aggregator by kole78 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @01:17PM (#35171575)
Updated. Thanks for the feedback!
Re:Launch HN: Propify (YC W23) – Real Estate API Aggregator by jxramos on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:08PM (#35172384)
what's the deal with MLS data? That sounds pretty interesting, some kind of protective moat they have in place? What's the backstory there?
Re:Launch HN: Propify (YC W23) – Real Estate API Aggregator by ramesh31 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @07:56PM (#35176350)
>what's the deal with MLS data? That sounds pretty interesting, some kind of protective moat they have in place? What's the backstory there?

It's just extremely valuable, so they won't give it out willy nilly. There's a network effect at work, where it's almost impossible to sell your home without listing with them, so everyone does. And mortgages are just about the most lucrative consumer financial transaction there is, so lots of incentive to keep it on lock.

Re:Launch HN: Propify (YC W23) – Real Estate API Aggregator by jxramos on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @08:00PM (#35176382)
interesting, blocking out the buyers at least

""" Can buyers access the multiple listing service without a realtor?

The short answer is no, they can’t — at least not directly. In order to access the MLS, you need a real estate license, which means it’s not possible for buyers to have direct access to this data on their own. However, they can reap the benefits the MLS has to offer if they start the house buying process off right and partner with a local real estate agent. """ https://listwithclever.com/real-estate-blog/get-access-mls-w....

Re:Launch HN: Propify (YC W23) – Real Estate API Aggregator by Dbtabachnik on Saturday March 18, 2023 @12:51PM (#35210701)
Why do you only focus on residential PMS's? From my perspective, I think commercial property management would have a larger opportunity to leverage APIs for market analytics, pro formas analysis using KPIs talked about in earlier parts of this thread, and DD (historically one of the biggest pain points for RE).

Credentials: Sr Product Manager at Amazon in the RE Team (Amazon Fulfillment), former BTS commercial property developer, and current luxury residential Real Estate agent with MLS access.