I like the MTR, but I think the NYC subway is better. For one thing, most of the lines in Manhattan are four tracks, allowing for express service. The MTR's coverage is also very sparse; most of the island is not in walking distance of an MTR station and you have to take minibusses.
The Ocotopus card is better-implemented than most of the similar systems I've used in the US, specifically because reading the card is properly debounced. In Chicago, using the RFID card to ride the bus is always difficult because if the card becomes readable, unreadable, and readable again very quickly, you get an error message even though your card was charged for the fare.
Not only is it easy to get around in HK without a car, it's often easier than driving, parking, tolls, etc (owning a car is a huge status symbol).
Whenever I think about mass transport, I'm reminded of the Planetary Transit System [1] from Sid Meier's Alpha Centauri game... Hong Kong is much closer to the "gas" state than any other place I've been.
[1] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eutDVI_egGM