There won't be any ads, because people would just use their phones instead which don't have ads. Specifically Google Live Transcribe, Otter and the like. Those require a data connection to the network, but there are versions that don't need the network at all. E.g. Chrome's Live Caption option. Eventually as technology becomes more power efficient and miniaturized it won't need to be paired to a phone.
The advantage of glasses is that people find it very distracting seeing a phone scrolling away, my GP stares at the phone instead of me because he is fascinated by it. Sometimes you can't be holding a phone up if something is being worked on. The glasses would also allow for a bit more directionality. It's a promising tool depending on how well it is implemented.
the problem isn't that it's worse than a cell phone. The problem is that it isn't any better. All of the privacy and security problems that exist with cell phones now exist with this product. You're locked in to using a cell phone which, for most people, is a hardware platform that Google controls and exploits at your expense.
You can't secure your cell phone and keep it private, and so nothing on your cell phone should be assumed to be secure or private.
If I'm in my doctors office, or working with a client, or doing anything where I don't want Google and who knows who else listening I can turn off my phone, or put it away, or leave it at home, and be reasonably sure that I'm not being eavesdropped on (there's always some risk of three letter agencies listening, but you can't do anything about that), but that's not an option if I need my phone to transcribe every word being said to me and even in situations where I currently leave my phone on it isn't normally sending every word it hears to the cloud to transcribe and send back to me either.
I like that this can work with a cell phone app, but it'd be much better if it could be used entirely offline, and ideally on different hardware as well, including a PC.
Imagine being able to run something like this entirely offline connected to something the size of an ipod or even a nano running linux. Imagine being able to build your own tools to interface with it. Add your own substitutions/annotations to real time text. Add dictionaries, or translation features.
This could be really cool even life-changing tech for people, or it could just be one more technology that's convenient but ultimately used to exploit people.
I suppose it would be a nice feature if they saved all of your conversations for later? The translations are too imperfect for any legal matter use.
The answers to this determine everything. Treating privacy-first as the moral and ethical default we should expect everyone to start from is a wonderful idea, rooted in compassion, kindness, and a foundational respect for human rights. It has also been an abject failure to date.
We should not expect the future to be different unless we are willing to be realistic about the economics at work. Otherwise the market gap will remain in the realm of the wonderfully hypothetical forever.
the fact is that no amount of money a customer can pay will ever be worth more than taking that customer's money and then also selling every scrap of data that your product can get its hands on on top of it.
We need to stop accepting "But I can make more money by screwing you" as a valid excuse for how things are. It's true, but still not okay. If the economics are always going to favor exploiting people, than I guess if we don't want to be exploited we need some very powerful regulations and all of the oversight and enforcement that requires in place to change that situation. I'd prefer that to blind faith and optimism. Until then, there are a number of things we should be insisting on in products as consumers to help protect ourselves. "works offline" is a really good one in a lot of situations.
https://github.com/TeamOpenSmartGlasses/OpenSourceSmartGlass...
ASR is done locally on the user's phone.
I hadn't thought that you would be, but I don't know anyone who hasn't had at least one service they used change their terms for the worse over time, especially once it becomes successful or ownership/management changes. Better to safeguard against such problems before they are problems than come to depend on a device like this only to find yourself stuck when the rug gets pulled out from under you.
> We are soon to release purely on-device transcription
This is really great! It's so important that people don't have to worry that things said between them and a lover, or a doctor, or a client, or a therapist is going to end up exposed to anyone else.
If you really want this device to be able to help people without opening them up to exploitation, please try to develop it to be as open as possible. Making it easy for developers to use it with whatever other hardware they like (a PC vs a cell phone), or extend it by adding new or customized functionality would be ideal and could help people in ways you hadn't even considered.
This is a cool product and a great use of the technology, and I'd love to be able to recommend it without reservation.
I doubt it. This isn't the kind of cheap mass-market device where running ads is going to make you a big profit.
This product is already targeting some specific demographics. I'm sure a lot of people would be willing to fork over money for access to those eyes just as I'm sure a lot of people will want access to what's being said or looked at. It'd be very nice if we didn't have to worry about that sort of thing at all, but here we are.
This is cool tech, that could be used to help people, but it comes with lots of potential for new forms of evil that were not possible without it. Considering that I can't remember the last time I bought a product using a new technology that wasn't also designed to work against my interests, I'm immediately skeptical of any device that can't be used offline and especially one that requires being connected to cell phone apps.