Re:The Door Close Button
by bmn__ on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @03:37PM
(#35157182)
The rabbinic explanation goes, if god didn't want his people to show cleverness in exploiting the loopholes, he wouldn't have put them there.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The Door Close Button
by deanCommie on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @05:40PM
(#35159232)
While the Judaic God definitely seems more good-natured than the Catholic one (at least in this one regard), as an Atheist, to be so close to the point and still miss it is some /r/selfawarewolves level rage.
> he wouldn't have put them there
Yes...that's right....he didn't.
Re:The Door Close Button
by jakeinspace on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @06:09PM
(#35159704)
Fascinating, tell us more
Maybe God gave Moses specific guidance on elevator use on sabbaths, it just got lost in translation because Moses had no clue what God was talking about
"Thou shalt not... elevator... buttons may not be... oh whatever, just put something in there about adultery."
That's a weird take. For the little I know about most religions, intent and the spirit of the law is what's important. God doesn't need evidence or justification, it just knows. Allowing workarounds is encouraging trickery, which seems at odds with the function of religion as moral guidance and social cohesion.
I personally don't have any problem with the idea of exploiting loopholes, I mean, it is Hacker News, and cleverness and exploiting loopholes is pretty much the definition of being a hacker. But from a religion perspective, it looks more like an atheist, or even satanist value.