News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by hsn915 on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @08:19AM (#35150293)
No country other than your country of origin owes you a right to stay.

It's not inhumane or something to have visa only for work and not for indefinite residency. If the work visa was defacto a permanent residency visa, no one would give it and no one would get it.

Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by AdamN on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @08:32AM (#35150417)
Hopefully we can change that in the future - people have been displaced over the centuries (and worse) but what you're saying is such a 20th century phenomenon that I'd like to see us move forward to better structures.
Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by hsn915 on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @08:46AM (#35150597)
Hopefully that does not change in the future. If anyone could just go anywhere that would be a terrible dystopian future.
Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by the_af on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @09:09AM (#35150856)
Why?
Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by mantas on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @01:55PM (#35155582)
There're many small countries where natives could be easily outnumbered by newcomers.
Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by the_mar on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @09:50AM (#35151484)
Right fuck those people who want to live outside of the place they were born in. /s
Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by mantas on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @01:54PM (#35155571)
No, let people in other places live as they're used to and don't get overrun and outpriced of their home.
Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by the_mar on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @02:07PM (#35155838)
Your outrage is misplaced. I am an immigrant tech worker, I too can't afford shit in San Francisco. I do not think immigrants are the problem here
Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by mantas on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @04:41PM (#35174420)
SF is a problem is we'd consider any non-San Franciscans as immigrants. And, given size of US, it would be correct. I'm really sorry for the old San Franciscans of the old era. It sucks when your city becomes a magnet of big money.
Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by the_mar on Saturday March 18, 2023 @01:08PM (#35210911)
Well, the opposite, as in your city falling in despair sure sucks more.

People wanting to live in San Francisco aren’t the problem, housing red tape and nimbys are

Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by suddenclarity on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @08:56AM (#35150712)
How is it a 20th century phenomenon? In the past we had barely no movement in comparison with today and at least here you actually had to apply for permission to move away.

The whole welfare system is based on the requirement that it only applies to a selected few and adults today support the elderly so they can retire under the assumption that children will pay the adults for their retirement. If you open up the welfare system for 7 billion people that haven't contributed, it will all collapse.

Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by the_mar on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @09:49AM (#35151459)
Btw people on work visas have no access to welfare, despite paying taxes that fund the welfare just the same.

Permanent residents have some access to welfare, but there isn’t a straightforward path from work visa to green card.

Who is suggesting US welfare has to support 7 billion people?

Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by suddenclarity on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @03:47PM (#35157305)
> Who is suggesting US welfare has to support 7 billion people?

That's the result from advocating free movement or no borders considering stats such as 52% of Africa's youth wanting to relocate to Europe or US. Unless you dismantle the welfare state. But it's possible that I misunderstood what the person meant with the 20th century comment.

Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by the_mar on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @08:30AM (#35167237)
No one is advocating for no borders here. Most people are saying that the time given to h1b visa holders to find a new job is too short.

Opening US borders for a free-for-all would be of course a disaster. But even that is a bit of a stretch to say that entire world’s population would move to the US.

Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by AdamN on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @04:37AM (#35165471)
> In the past we had barely no movement in comparison with today

People used to be highly mobile (and continue to be). The Americas were settled by millions of Europeans and Africans before the United States even became a country. South Asians were moved to Africa during the colonial era en masse. Vikings settled all over Europe and even Istanbul. The Huns, Goths, Romans, were all on the move.

Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by inertiatic on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @08:21AM (#35150303)
And your country owes you why?
Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by tdsanchez on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @08:29AM (#35150402)
"And your country owes you why?"

Because its a UN convention.

https://www.unhcr.org/un-conventions-on-statelessness.html

Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by mihaic on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @08:25AM (#35150346)
That's the general social contract that most people have as their mental model: "If I pay my taxes and do my part, my children will get the standard benefits of citizenship".

Honestly, I'm not sure what use you see from asking this question.

Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by lordnacho on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @08:31AM (#35150413)
It's part of the socratic method.

It's reasonable to ask why your country of birth owes you anything. Keep in mind not every country gives you citizenship from birth, so it raises the question of whether what you're saying really is correct.

I would suggest if someone has worked somewhere for a decent amount of time they should not be disposed of so easily as the person in the article.

Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by hsn915 on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @08:44AM (#35150571)
> It's part of the socratic method.

But that question wasn't. It was bad faith "gotcha!" question.

Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by lordnacho on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @08:54AM (#35150695)
I don't think so. The question is short but it illuminates an angle most people wouldn't think of. Or when they think of it, there's no satisfactory answer immediately apparent.

There's why does any country owe you, and why does your country of origin in particular owe you.

Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by the_af on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @09:03AM (#35150793)
I understand your overall point and agree with it, but let me state that "paying my taxes" is such an American, money-centered worldview.

Your country owes you citizenship even if you don't pay your taxes. It may punish you in other ways, but not by taking away citizenship.

Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by widge on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @08:27AM (#35150367)
Because if it is attacked, you have to defend it. This obligation to your country gives you the right to stay in it.
Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by lordnacho on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @08:44AM (#35150572)
Corollaries:

- People who can't "defend the country" don't get these rights: women, children, old people, people with religious exemptions, people with an unreasonable fear of being violently killed.

- People who promise to come and defend will get these rights, regardless of where they were born? Do they just make a solemn oath or do they have to do boot camp and maintain their skills?

I hope you can see this is not where your rights come from.

Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by the_af on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @09:06AM (#35150824)
You don't lose citizenship if you refuse to defend your country. Depending on the country, you may be jailed, fined or otherwise punished, but most countries won't take your citizenship away from you if you refuse to fight.
Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by hsn915 on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @08:43AM (#35150557)
You could argue that even your country doesn't owe you anything merely for existing. You have responsibilities, not just rights.

But for the purpose of this discussion, I'm assuming a person already has a country they belong to which does give them the right to stay.

No other country owes you the right to stay. Singapore does not owe me the right to be there, let alone stay there. Each country is free to decide the rules for who it allows in and how long it allows them to stay and under what conditions.

It's not a "human right".

Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by rileymat2 on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @08:56AM (#35150711)
One thing that I would like to push back on the idea that “It is not a ‘human right’”.

A “human right” is a social term defined by the demands of the people living in that time collectively. There is no list we can check off, it is what people demand and can fight for.

By asserting the right they very well could be /creating/ it.

Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by mantas on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @02:00PM (#35155683)
With your definition of „human rights“ we can just abolish the term altogether.

The beauty of human rights was that it was supposed to be a well-defined set of core things. Which can't be granted, they just shouldn't be stamped on. But now „human rights“ is becoming a very polarised topic with many bits where person A is forced to do provide something to person B because it's „human rights“. Does person A has a „human right“ to refuse to provide his service?

Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by rileymat2 on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @07:19PM (#35160860)
I think you are making a distinction between positive rights and negative rights; not human rights.

If it was supposed to be a a well-defined set of core things, where are you drawing that set from?

Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by mantas on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @04:39PM (#35174402)
IMO human rights is a subset of negative rights.

Can it be a non-questionable human right to force others to provide you something?

Granting people that others will provide them something is fine. But it must be possible to discuss such topics. Human rights, IMO, shall be a very pure set of things that are not up to discussion, even with rather fringe views. Regardless of political quadrant. Of course, some freaks will always question anything. But wide wide majority (think 95% if not 98%) shall sign off on that.

Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by lordnacho on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @08:52AM (#35150673)
So where do stateless people such as myself belong (not stateless now, but previously)? There's corner cases in every rule, but there can be a lot of cases where people slip through the cracks.
Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by hsn915 on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @11:57PM (#35163658)
That's another discussion though. The topic at hand is someone who has a country and had an opportunity to work in another country is complaining that they have to go back to their home country because the work visa is not a permanent residence visa.
Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by hotpotamus on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @08:44AM (#35150576)
If humans were merely fully replaceable units in the machinery that is a nation (and it seems that this is the goal of many of the elite), then that would make sense. But many humans actually form communities and welcome new residents in. Some of these newcomers become part of the community and even create new members.
Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by the_gipsy on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @08:47AM (#35150602)
Why even your country of origin? Okay, they can't just pick another country and shove people there, that's not fair and no country would accept that, but they could maybe dump unwanted people in the ocean. Just a thought.
Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by hsn915 on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @08:49AM (#35150626)
Because humans are cooperative creatures, and if a society can't establish cooperation between its members, chaos will ensue.
Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by unmole on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @08:47AM (#35150603)
Except for the fact that except for Indians, everyone else can get a green card after a few years on a H1-B.
Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by krisoft on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @08:48AM (#35150623)
> It's not inhumane or something to have visa only for work and not for indefinite residency.

It is in fact inhumane. It is also "or something" if you mean "unethical" by that.

The purpose of the arrangement is to obtain easy to exploit workforce to undercut the one locally available. The fact that it is precarious and exploitative is not an accident, but the goal.

Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by hsn915 on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @08:53PM (#35162122)
By your characterization of the problem, the solution would seem to be to abolish work visas all together, and not allow any foriegners to stay for mere work.
Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by kiliantics on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @08:55AM (#35150707)
What if there is a country which has had a strong influence over turning your country of origin into a place that is very difficult to live in?
Re:60 Days to Find a Job or Leave the Country by the_mar on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @09:07AM (#35150836)
Most countries have a path to permanent residency after 5 years of gainful employment in the said country. In the us it is a quota based on your nationality or a lottery system. Why should it matter how many other people from X country applied for a GC that year if I worked in the US for 10 years and paid hundreds of thousands of dollars in taxes?