When I was younger we lived about an hour away from the city. There was a gas station and a small grocery store near the out-of-the-way suburb where I lived. That was it. Getting my first car was a life-changing event for me that basically allowed me to become as independent as I am today, and 'going out for a drive' was just something I did as a young teen trying to keep himself entertained and trying to find new things to do. I ended up finding a Navy recruiter, but that's a different story.
I'm aware that the costs associated with this 'One Person - One Car' idea might not be scalable over the long term, and we should probably start offloading some of the costs associated with maintaining this paradigm onto the city driver while providing good alternatives. But I will always have a vehicle, no matter what it costs me.
The greatest freedom of all is the ability to use your own legs to take you to where you want to go. Your idea of freedom changes when you live in a walkable area and realize that you don't have to rely on anything other than yourself to get you to most things in life.
But... I simply cannot understand the desire to live in such close proximity to large numbers of other people. Never ever again will I subject myself to high density living. I live in a suburb and simply hate having to go downtown especially when there are big events going on. The bars are crowded, eating establishments are packed, noisy has hell. Won't do it, you can't make me!
I like the quiet, I like being able to walk into a suburban bar and not have to shoulder my way through a crowd to try to find a seat if one is even available. It's nice to simply walk in, sit down on a bar stool and actually hear the game on the TV. I like not having the noise of a city outside my window when I sleep.
The greatest freedom of all is that either of us can make the choice of what lifestyle suits us.
It would be lovely if we could choose which lifestyle suits us, but most of the cities in the US do not provide ANY option for someone who wants proper high-density, so to exercise my "freedom" to live in a pedestrian friendly high-density city involved leaving the US entirely.
The bars are crowded, eating establishments are packed, noisy has hell.
But how many of those people drove to the downtown area because there were no equivalent establishments within walking distance of their suburban homes? Not trying being a dick, of course, just pointing out the chicken and egg nature of the problem.However, if I go to a "destination" for out-of-towners[1], then yes: it's packed, noisy, and insufferable.
Same thing with traffic -- most of the personal automobile traffic in the cities comes from commuters that don't live here.
[1] I was trying really hard not to say "bridge and tunnel" ...
There are definite advantages to living in an area where you rarely need a vehicle, but I will always want to own one anyway. :-)
Subsidized conveniences when you add it all up, really.
> when it clearly works fairly well the way it is
Aside from the traffic, smog, and high number of accidental deaths directly attributable to automobile traffic, you mean?
Which is to say, yeah, I suppose we're selfish, but then again, owning property is selfish, comrade.
Also, as an aside, try riding a bike about 5 ~ 10 miles when it's 105 degrees out (pretty common where I live), or even hovering around zero (fairly common where I used to live). It's not fun, nor is it practical. It's a big part of why nobody does it.
They exist in most of the developed world; North America is the major exception. All that's required to create them here is good public policy, which was the topic to begin with.
I get the same feeling of freedom from walking, except I'm not really dependent on the presence of roads.
Of course our country is overrun by cars, including our cities. The government has enacted policies that encourage car driving above other transportation means. This in turn has encouraged suburbanization, which, as you point out, generally requires a car-centric lifestyle.
There is nothing wrong with suburbanization, but we wouldn't have nearly the extent of suburbs that we have now if all transportation options were on equal footing. And it shouldn't be the governments job to make car travel so cheap that people buy large, cheap houses in the middle of nowhere.
This also ignores all the other costs of car-centric living such as increased risks for obesity, heart disease, depression, etc. If you live in a walkable area, you naturally walk a lot more and get daily exercise. The idea that you would need to go to a gym to get exercise in your daily life is one of the reasons that Americans are becoming so unhealthy.
This is basically what I'm thinking these days. Having suburbs is fine. What's really killing us, is the incredibly low density of those suburbs, caused by zoning and the hiding of transportation costs that subsidize that zoning.
It's the cul-de-sac neighborhoods and massive parking lots sitting idle 90% of the time that make suburbs unwalkable and impractical to service with public transport. If the suburbs themselves weren't so sparse, their residents wouldn't need to use their cars as much and transport options for getting into the city, or to neighboring suburbs would greatly alleviate traffic and increase freedom for those who can't drive, can't afford to drive or just would prefer not to.
You can literally see the difference in walkability and infrastructure service levels between suburban neighborhoods built in the 50s and those built in the late 70s and later.
One has consistent street and infrastructure grids, parks, likely bus stops (because they're feasible) and commercial-cluster downtown areas for goodness sake! While the other has larger yards, cul-de-sacs, inconsistent sidewalks and the closest they come to a downtown is a (likely now decrepit) mall with its own ocean of usually-empty parking and the commensurate traffic-snarling entrances and exits.
But front yards are nothing but unused space that increase sprawl.
I'm not 100% convinced by this line of reasoning. All major forms of travel (including walking) can be seen as "supported" by government policies and money. If nothing else, eminent domain plays a huge role in transportation infrastructure.
I don't think we can build infrastructure like this piece at a time to see which one wins. So there is no true "equal footing" or "fair" approach that everyone can agree on.
I think we're touching here some fundamental problems of governance and city-planning.
a) what should the role of goverment be?
b) cities dont have those clear-cut borders as administrations have (ultra-dense areas somewhat evolve into rural areas as you drive outside of a city)
c) thus multiple layers of government and morality are involved in shaping our cities
I think providing people with more choices is usually the better policy, thus suburbia has its right to stay. My experience though is, that in suburbia you often end up with the worst of both worlds: the crime, dirt, traffic and anonymity of cities as well as the unacessability of culture, services and long commute times of rural areas. So I'd rather go all-in citywise or stay out of the whole thing at all. but then this is the personal preference of a 20-somewhat and not your typical young family founder who may strive for suburbia.
PS: Roads are really expensive if you compare road infrastructure costs to miles driven you need a ~3$ / gallon gas tax to break even. Anything less than that and your just subsidizing cars which does not lower costs it just hides them.
"The problem with buses for transport is they use the same infrastructure as cars" IMHO this is to be considered as advantage over light-rail. There is no additional infrastructure to be built or maintained.
From what I've read, developers think similarly: they're willing to invest capital in housing developments near rail-transit lines, but not on the basis of bus lines, because they need to be able to assume that the transit situation will be stable for long enough to pay off their investment. In other words, the flexibility of buses is precisely the problem, because it means residents/developers/employers can't rely on them in making plans.
I think a lot more urban public transportation could be achieved by tackling your mentioned correlation: Property owners benefit by far the most from public transport infrastructure errected nearby their property (at least if underground or not noisy etc.).
Even if the owner's property taxes rise, the tax increase usually lacks behind the actual property value increase by some years up to a decade.
So if I want to solve it politically I'd:
1) get rid of that lacking-behind in property valuation. Then
2) maybe add the expectalbe increased property-tax income to my calculation when planning a new subway line
3) consider talking to owners. if a subway line is to be errected, I'd propose to owners that I'am willing to errect stations nearby their property if they participate in the costs.
I believe that in most places in the US, your suggestion that nearby property owners might support nearby transit to the extent of partially paying for it would be a non-starter. Usually, nearby (say, within 200m of the route) property owners oppose new bus/train routes tooth and claw.
One of the most famous examples of anti-transit sentiment from property owners is the congressional bill that Henry Waxman (a generally liberal Democrat) got passed, prohibiting a subway extension from downtown Los Angeles toward the ocean (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Westside_Subway_Extension_(Los_...).
About 25 years later, this law was lifted, but a lot of the sentiment remains.
I have come to believe that most anti-gentrification sentiment, at least where I live in LA, is misplaced. It's a young city and to expect neighborhoods to stay the same on the time scale of decades is unrealistic. There are laws (many mistaken, IMHO) to prevent property taxes from rising more than about 2% per year, so nobody will be forced from their home. Renters may have to move, although there are rent protections on many properties also.
Anyway, anti-gentrification sentiment is interesting because it never stops. People who moved to my neighborhood in 2000 think the 2010'ers are gentrifiers. People who moved here in 1990 think it's the 2000'ers. People who moved here in 1970 think it's anyone after 1980.
Most resentment and name-calling about "gentrification" is among the young, however. By contrast, NIMBYism is more of a middle-age and old person's thing. At least where I live.
Excactly! Where does one draw the line? Usually one draws the line so that protection includes himself. For me, it's a moral problem as well, because this line-drwaring scales up to elections that justify way too much government regulation. From my perspective anti-gentrification sentiment is almost always misplaced.
"By contrast, NIMBYism is more of a middle-age and old person's thing."
Maybe the difference is also, that NIMBY-ians engage proactivly against changes (they know that where they live is already good), where as anti-gentrificationists seem to be more reactionary (not anybody expected sudden price rises to occur).
Where I connect NIMBY- and anti-gentrification-sentiments is that one want's prohibit things to change (anti-immigration, trade restrictions). All of those sentiments are understandable. But prohibiting things from change via legislation tends to be an unfair deal for future generations. The change I don't want to happen is an opportunity that for many will never occur.
"to expect neighborhoods to stay the same on the time scale of decades is unrealistic."
Absolutely. In Hamburg there are restrictions on building heights. The most stupid one is, that in downtown 'no bulding should block the view of the churches'. It's the one place in Hamburg, where land is so expensive that buildings need to rise in height if you want affordable rent prices. But the buildings can't rise, so no one lives there anymore. Thus the churches have lost their communities and downtown is a dead place after 8pm. Just one example where the attitude of "conserving culture" leads to killing it off.
Update:
Took a while for me to find it, but to prove that anti-gentrification really never stops, take st.tropez/côte d'azur france, where the millionaires don't wan't the billionaires to come in http://www.amb-cotedazur.com/Did-you-know/rich-russians-are-...
Consistent market research and experience over the last 50 years in Europe and North America shows that car commuters are willing to transfer some trips to rail-based public transport but not to buses. Typically light rail systems attract between 30 and 40% of their patronage from former car trips. Rapid transit bus systems attract less than 5% of trips from cars, less than the variability of traffic.[42]
That said, buses are cheaper than new roads so most city's adopt them at some point. The real issues IMO is most city's are going to be around in 100 years and need to think in those terms. When you look at New York and other major city's you see how development and public transport are closely linked and light rail continues to gain value even in competition with cars and buses.
If you have the space for a dedicated right-of-way you might as well go full out and make high-cap rail. Otherwise, I see light rail as the worst compromise in-between subways and buses. There's a reason Manhattan has essentially eliminated all at-grade light rail, and elevated rail still exists only in the relatively poor neighborhoods: wherever the subway doesn't run, buses are best at filling the gap without destroying the street-level environment.
I've always thought that was their #1 selling point. Light rails are just insanely expensive. When you've already got roads in place, buses become very attractive.
A tram system can be fully automated.
An electric engine is more efficient (constant torque) in an urban area with lots of stops.
In countries like those in Eastern Europe, car drivers don't give a fk about buses and bus lanes. But they are scared enough to make way for the trams (if they collide, the tram will barely be scratched while their car ends up totally smashed).
The tram vehicle lasts more time. My town uses 50 year old trams without any issues, while the buses must be replaced after 10-15 years.
I went car-less for about 6 months as an experiment. Initially, I tried to compute value from the local car sharing services, but it didn't compute. Plus, the nearby cars seemed to be heavily used, limiting availability. So, I never signed up with them. Instead, I discovered that with a little foresight and planning, I could get economy rentals from the big rental companies via priceline for like $12-15 a day. Of course, I had to pay for the gas, but insurance was covered by my credit card. It worked out well for times when I had to commute outside the urban area.
Inside the urban area of DC, I found that driving was extremely painful with traffic and parking, but oftentimes it was still less hassle than trying to get around the DC metro system. The DC metro system doesn't work. The train system has frequent delays, huge time gaps between trains, over-packed cars, limited times of operation, and trips are expensive. Furthermore, the bus system seems to have bizarre, unoptimized routes.
Anyway, I really want car-sharing to work, but it seems like it can only work in some geographical areas, under certain conditions, and with some local support. But, I'm always looking forward to new ideas in transportation; it's one of the worst parts of living in DC.
About DC:
I've been to DC once for a couple of days. For tourist destinations the metro was fine, even though Georgetown seemed to be unaccessible due to its residents refusing a metro connection there (fear of gentrification?). Also the similarity of the stations made orientation from inside the train different for newcomers.
I've also used the the SmartBike DC, which wasn't nice, since there are few bike lanes.
About car sharing:
My experience is that car sharing is cheaper than rental if you're using the car for less than 6-12 hours a day. But your right, those numbers work differently from town to town. As soon as I added expectable car price decline to the monthly costs of owning, car sharing became incredibly cheap. I'm also happy to not have to deal with maintanance and tax/insurance issues. If I'd had to travel by car daily, owning/leasing a car would still be the cheapest option.
I agree that maintenance-related delays on evenings and weekends can be significant, and packed Orange Line cars are a real problem. Hopefully the former will go away as the current round of maintenance is completed; we'll probably need to build a second Potomac River tunnel and the M St subway to resolve the latter.
He focuses less on the differences between bus and light rail (unimportant distinction) and more on what it means to actually provide mobility that people can use. Rail vs bus is about as useful as emacs vs vi - fun for practitioners, useless for users that care about code or getting places in their life.
Cars improve the lives of drivers with increased range movement, more time independent movement (start your journey when it suits you, not when a timetable allows you to) and allow for more freight to be carried.
When cars are criticized for bringing down the quality of life it is mostly an issue in urban environments. People in rural or suburban areas rely heavily on cars. The car may even have saved the quality of life in rural areas (ie stopped/slowed down the flight from those areas into cities) while it's what makes the existance of modern suburbia possible. It therefor provides cheaper housing and a broader choice of how you want to live (Not everybody needs five starbucks and a movie theatre in the neighbourhood). They also slowed the population increase of cities.
Adding costs to drivers in urban areas mean higher burdens for people that have to commute by car, since suburban/rural areas are too thinly populated to allow for efficient public transportation.
The quality of life argument often tends to demonize technological progress and romanticizes the past. The funny thing is, that this romance is only possible because technologies provided us with spare time. So did motorization. People who lived back then, would have always opted for the new technologies.
That being said, cars do decrease urban quality of life in certain ways. But it is important to not let generalization allow for bad policies. Light Rail for instance is alwas proposed, while it costs more than individual motorized traffic and while rail tracks usually decrease nearby quality of life more than any road could.
I'd propose simpler measures:
1) stop providing free parking. Allow the parking space usage to be priced at what the value of that land would have provided in real property taxes, if it had been tilled with a house. There's an interesting book about the "cost of free parking" by an UCLA Professor http://www.uctc.net/papers/351.pdf
2) get rid of cab driving restrictions to dramatically lower cab fair prices. cities with limited amounts of cab driving licenses have higher fair costs. A NY cab medallion is considered a better investment than gold http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2011-08-31/ny-cab-medallions-w...
3) If property owners where to decide, they'd propably opt more likely for narrowing the streets and expanding sidewalks as it would increase their properties value. BID (business improvement districts) often do this. Enable more owners to make those decisions.
4) start with yourself and ditch your car if you don't need it. Do you really need more range? Do you really need to be able to start your journey every minute and not just every 10 minutes. And do you always need to be able to haul up to 4 fridges? And thus do
5) car sharing. i'm a very satisfied user of http://www.car2go.com/ and similar services.
6) if there's a growing need for light-rail, chances are, this need could have already been eliminated by using more buses for public transport.