But as malware authors find more holes and use more exploits it becomes harder to know what's safe or not. Having some weird defaults in operating systems (don't show file extensions; perform an action based on the extension and not the type of file; build a web-browser into the OS; use a preview pane that auto-opens a lot of things so you don't need to "open" an email message it's been opened for you by the pre-installed email client etc etc) really didn't help.
There's also a problem with users. (This comment in not aimed at you!) Some operating systems have very many users who believe themselves to be clueful but who really really are not. The arrogant 19 year old who can slot together a motherboard and GPU and PSU and put them in a case, who can connect his aunt's computer to the Internet, who can install add-ons to his web browser. These are people who think they know what they're doing, who think that the pirated OS they use is fine because they checked an MD5 hash, and who think the pirated software they use is fine because someone would have said something in the torrent comments if it wasn't. And then, if they have a problem, they'll download a pirate AV and hope that isn't infected. These are the people most mocking of the "wipe and re-install; that's the only safe option" philosophy. They'll spend a day using various bits of anti-malware and scanners and web-searching. And they won't find the infected WMV file and they'll get re-infected a few days later.
AVs are a first-line and an indication that something is wrong. If you need to run the AV to clean an actual, real virus, you should be reloading the machine.
On my personal machine, I don't run any anti-virus software, but I also don't use adobe pdf and enable flash only on sites I trust.