Re:Ivy League Schools Sure Look Like a Cartel
by pyuser583 on Sunday March 12, 2023 @01:09PM
(#35122806)
That’s a really great question -
* in the case of my college, I knew what I wanted, and was shopping around for it. The major was a very unusual one - not even a major as much as a program (“great books”).
* in the case of my daughter, I knew the school because I had taught there decades ago.
* there are admissions consultants who keep track of these sorts of things and make it a point to know all the side doors.
At the end of the day, colleges admissions should be about matching students and colleges who fit together. If a student isn’t as competitive, but is still a great fit, they should I get extra points for that.
But this can be come a system those with money abuse. But that abuse takes the form of lying about whether they are a good fit for the college they are going to - which is dumb.
If a student gets into Harvard by saying they really want to pursue the newly introduced degree of “Diversity, Equity, Inclusion” - is Harvard really a good fit?
* in the case of my college, I knew what I wanted, and was shopping around for it. The major was a very unusual one - not even a major as much as a program (“great books”).
* in the case of my daughter, I knew the school because I had taught there decades ago.
* there are admissions consultants who keep track of these sorts of things and make it a point to know all the side doors.
At the end of the day, colleges admissions should be about matching students and colleges who fit together. If a student isn’t as competitive, but is still a great fit, they should I get extra points for that.
But this can be come a system those with money abuse. But that abuse takes the form of lying about whether they are a good fit for the college they are going to - which is dumb.
If a student gets into Harvard by saying they really want to pursue the newly introduced degree of “Diversity, Equity, Inclusion” - is Harvard really a good fit?