Few of the explainers are covering both parts of this.
This was a liquidity crisis (bank run) which sparked a solvency issue, not a solvency issue.
Imagine if they put 100% of their deposits in these bonds, they would not be able to raise the interest rates they pay out above like 1.5% for the next 10 years, because they're stuck with their own long term investment. When other banks start offering a better interest rate on savings, of course people will want to withdraw.
So even if they are solvent by definition this is not the same thing as a liquidity crisis that results from an inability to sell a large amount of something in a short time, potentially something that is difficult to sell. It's not the amount or the weirdness of the asset here, it's the price they are locked into, the same way that anyone trying to sell any amount of this right now would be taking a loss if they bought in 2021. And it's not like the price is some irrational situation like GameStop, it's a natural consequence of the interest rates.
I don't see how this wasn't a predictably risky trade regardless of the VC panic factor. They put 40% of their deposits into a long term bet that interest rates wouldn't go up.
This was a liquidity crisis (bank run) which sparked a solvency issue, not a solvency issue.
No. SVB had liabilities significantly in excess of the value of their assets. They were, by definition, balance sheet insolvent.
The "hold to maturity" accounting practice made it legal for them to pretend that the value of their long term bonds hadn't changed, but that's just an accounting figleaf; the actual value of those bonds had factually dropped.
At the same time the flip side of this is that many of those startups aren't profitable and in the absence of a FDIC bailout, those startups' employees (who are typically not paid that well to begin with) may not get their next paycheck and thus it still is directly impacting individuals and families.
Yep. To me it seems like one of the monster banks will gladly pick this up. They can handle the short term liquidity then cash out massively on the long term investments.
Worth noting though that based on what I’ve read, the bank has plenty of assets to repay depositors… the issue is just that these assets aren’t super liquid. So if there was some form of bailout, it would be more of a bridge loan type deal than a true bailout assuming I understand the situation.