Re:Photographers face copyright threat after shock ruling
by clarkevans on Wednesday January 25, 2012 @09:56AM
(#3509894)
I think paragraph 37, where the judge quotes case law, is essential to understanding this case. The judge chooses to quote from a prior ruling and places emphasis this phrase:
"defendants deny infringement but they do not advance a case of independent design"
The judge then goes on later to note the defendant "could have simply instructed an independent photographer to go to Westminster and take a picture which includes at least a London bus, Big Ben and the Houses of Parliament"
In other words, this wasn't a clean room development, actual copying of design took place even though the no direct reproduction occurred. This seems to also mirror the AFC test for copyright infringement.
One you abstract out the stock materials, filter them for originality in design, and compare them, you conclude that the defendants work was indeed a copy of the essential creative elements and arrangement.
The judge then goes on later to note the defendant "could have simply instructed an independent photographer to go to Westminster and take a picture which includes at least a London bus, Big Ben and the Houses of Parliament"
In other words, this wasn't a clean room development, actual copying of design took place even though the no direct reproduction occurred. This seems to also mirror the AFC test for copyright infringement.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abstraction-Filtration-Comparis...
One you abstract out the stock materials, filter them for originality in design, and compare them, you conclude that the defendants work was indeed a copy of the essential creative elements and arrangement.