Re:Apple launches its new classical music streaming app for ...
by crazygringo on Thursday March 09, 2023 @12:55PM
(#35084298)
It's not just about organizing, though -- it's about social discovery.
It's about having a "current top composers" next to "current top artists".
It's about "current top songs" not having all 4 movements of a single work listed as separate songs. It's about the radio feature not randomly dropping you into the 17th track of an opera (with exceptions for certain arias).
It's about "people who listen to this composer also listen to..." along side "people who listen to this artist also listen to...".
But even organization was never fully solved in ID3, because it doesn't support multiple artists on a track (or multiple composers) in any standardized way. It's already a problem in popular music, but even worse in classical when both a conductor and a soloist and an orchestra are performing. ID3 doesn't have any way to group movements of a work together either -- you have to smush work and movement together in the title field.
It's about having a "current top composers" next to "current top artists".
It's about "current top songs" not having all 4 movements of a single work listed as separate songs. It's about the radio feature not randomly dropping you into the 17th track of an opera (with exceptions for certain arias).
It's about "people who listen to this composer also listen to..." along side "people who listen to this artist also listen to...".
But even organization was never fully solved in ID3, because it doesn't support multiple artists on a track (or multiple composers) in any standardized way. It's already a problem in popular music, but even worse in classical when both a conductor and a soloist and an orchestra are performing. ID3 doesn't have any way to group movements of a work together either -- you have to smush work and movement together in the title field.