News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I want to fix programming by icebraining on Tuesday January 24, 2012 @08:35PM (#3507951)
Isn't the beer example somewhat self-defeating? It seems to me that the only reason we don't need to tell our friends how to get the beer is because he has already those concepts abstracted away, but he still had to learn them, mostly by imitating others, but also by being explicitly taught.

Sure, he didn't have to be taught how to fetch a particular kind of beer in a particular house, but then again, when I make a new e.g. Starcraft map, I don't have to change the code to teach units to move from a coordinate to another. The learned algorithm is just general enough that it applies to any object that fits a certain interface.

And humans make a lot of errors to correct their internal spacial navigation algorithms. To correctly fetch a beer, it took years of bumping into stuff and falling down until the algorithm was robust enough.

Seems to me that a system with hand-written imperative algorithms and a general mechanism of iteratively improving them by trial-and-error is much more close to what we humans to than a compiler that simply comes up with algorithms from scratch from just reading intents and goals.

There are no comments on this comment yet.