News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New estimate for high-speed rail puts California train $1... by drannex on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @11:36PM (#35078362)
This project will easily create a 10x return in economic development within 5-10 years. Public transportation is an investment in your areas overall upward mobility for everyone and expand options and choices in ways that are entirely unheard of today.

If they don't build this now, then it will take and cost longer to build later.

Re:New estimate for high-speed rail puts California train $1... by the_optimist on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @11:46PM (#35078399)
Maybe we should invest 10x more and reap 100x the reward, in 5-10 years, nonetheless. It’s a money machine better than counterfeiting. You Cannot Lose.
Re:New estimate for high-speed rail puts California train $1... by ralph84 on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @11:52PM (#35078423)
You’re gonna have to show the math for $1 trillion in economic development in 5-10 years for a route that’s already served by air and road options in a state with stagnant population and declining usage of existing public transit.

We’re 27 years since the California High-Speed Rail Authority was established and not a single passenger has been carried yet.

Re:New estimate for high-speed rail puts California train $1... by monero-xmr on Thursday March 09, 2023 @01:37AM (#35078807)
But… trains! They are better! …because!
Re:New estimate for high-speed rail puts California train $1... by simplotek on Thursday March 09, 2023 @02:36AM (#35079078)
> (...) for a route that’s already served by air and road options in a state with stagnant population (...)

Mass transit systems have some peculiarities that private transportation systems don't have, such as creating mass demand and concentrating it on specific spots. Each train stop is a natural generator for demand for housing and services in volumes that urban sprawl does not, and this leads to more affordable housing with shorter commutes and with far better services that lead to a far better quality of living.

But this potential to be realized needs urban development that takes advantage of it, which require investment.

I'm not sure if the figure is $1T but there are examples in the world where railway operators get their main source of funding and incentive to grow their network by being granted favourable conditions to invest in real estate surrounding new train stops.

> (...) and declining usage of existing public transit.

I'm sorry, the US is notorious for having self-sabotaging public transportation services, designed to pay lip service for the need to provide mobility alternatives,but actually designed to be impactical and outright hostile to commuters.

If the US learns basic lessons from the many case studies from throughout the world, nothing stops the US from benefiting from identical adoption rates seen outside of its borders.

Re:New estimate for high-speed rail puts California train $1... by thecopy on Thursday March 09, 2023 @02:52AM (#35079155)
Stagnant public transit use is caused by bad public transit. Hence investments are needed. The USA’s transit is like a 3rd world country’s.
Re:New estimate for high-speed rail puts California train $1... by unmole on Thursday March 09, 2023 @12:32AM (#35078570)
> 10x return in economic development within 5-10 years.

That is an extraordinary claim. 10x of 100 billion is a trillion. The GSP of the entire state of California is ~3.5 trillion USD.

Re:New estimate for high-speed rail puts California train $1... by MichaelZuo on Thursday March 09, 2023 @03:34PM (#35086302)
It does seem kind of difficult to arrive at no matter how one calculates it.
Re:New estimate for high-speed rail puts California train $1... by philwelch on Thursday March 09, 2023 @12:39AM (#35078594)
This project will not carry a single passenger within the next 10 years.
Re:New estimate for high-speed rail puts California train $1... by diebeforei485 on Thursday March 09, 2023 @12:53AM (#35078658)
This is a jobs program not actually a transportation plan. The alignment was to create jobs in certain areas to win local elections, not to optimize transport.
Re:New estimate for high-speed rail puts California train $1... by tsuujin on Thursday March 09, 2023 @01:07AM (#35078698)
The problem with this project is that it has been so woefully mismanaged that in 5-10 years I have no hope any trains will actually be running.

I routinely drive by one of the overpasses built in the Central Valley, a constant reminder of a shattered dream of quick transit to the Bay Area.

Re:New estimate for high-speed rail puts California train $1... by ars on Thursday March 09, 2023 @04:44AM (#35079722)
For the amount of money this costs you could subsidize plane tickets for Californians and it would cost less money AND emit less CO2. 100 Billion worth of CO2 is enormous (to a rough estimate monetary cost is proportional to emissions).