News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:No More Résumés, Say Some Firms by tptacek on Tuesday January 24, 2012 @07:33PM (#3507728)
If it was 100/1, I'd agree with you, but these are never 100/1 processes; they're cutesy programming quizzes, or video requirements, or lengthy statements of required prior technical experience.

Any process that does not cause a cold high-quality lead to come into contact with an engaged human being almost automatically is broken.

Re:No More Résumés, Say Some Firms by yummyfajitas on Tuesday January 24, 2012 @08:29PM (#3507930)
If it's part of a hiring process, it doesn't need to be 100/1. You can chain bad filters together to get a good one - that's the basis of statistical prediction.

And incidentally, cutesy programming quizzes are often a very good filter. In my last job, I tried recruiting with one after speaking to too many people who couldn't handle fizzbuzz. The exact quote was "Instructions on where to send your resume are contained in our application (you'll need to decrypt them first)." http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1659735

It dramatically increased the number of people who wrote to me - I actually got quite a few responses of "neat puzzle, not looking for a job, did I get it right?" And by virtue of not giving out an unencrypted email address, I didn't talk to anyone who couldn't code.

Re:No More Résumés, Say Some Firms by tptacek on Tuesday January 24, 2012 @08:48PM (#3507991)
A false negative in a job filter results in a phone screen with someone who can't do fizzbuzz.

A false positive results in a candidate who can e.g. write a kernel memory allocator walking from your process because you're too much of a pain to deal with.

Too many interviews, or losing the best possible candidates. I know which one I prefer --- especially because I know when I'm getting too many interviews, and can tune other things (most notably: where I post about jobs) to adjust that. I can't know who I'm losing as a result of my recruiting process being cumbersome.

Re:No More Résumés, Say Some Firms by teyc on Wednesday January 25, 2012 @02:10AM (#3508700)
Perhaps the reverse way to look at the situation is that job adverts are so uninformative about the place where one might work, that it is the employers who should present a video about why one might want to work for them. It shouldn't be one of those glitzy HR ones, but rather one made with a cameraphone introducing the people the prospect will be working with, and some idea of what type of problem is being solved.

The other thing that jumps out at me is that instead of a cute challenge, it's probably more useful to provide a bug in 50 lines of code that you expect to "jump out" effortlessly for the qualified candidates, while less qualified might struggle a little.