Re:I want to fix programming
by protomyth on Tuesday January 24, 2012 @04:37PM
(#3506960)
The most common declarative programming language used in SQL. In theory the optimizer takes my declaration and builds an optimum (or at least decent) set of step in the database engine to accomplish what I have declared. With all the work in this limited area, database optimizers get it really wrong quite a lot (Sybase 12.5 was bad enough on big data that forcing order of joins and indexes was needed).
I am not sure we are at the stage where the computer can be trusted with the "what". Most new learners need to be told step by step the "how" and computers seem to be at that stage. Prolog is a nice counter-example, but even it can get itself into some real trouble.
I agree programming is broken, and I agree the whole program knowledge is just painful, but I am think there are some steps before full declarative. As much as I dislike the old VB, it did have a very vibrant component market. That concept didn't seem to evolve or make it to the server. I look at Mongrel2 and wonder if the component approach could be applied. Regardless, I think the biggest problem is lack of ability to separate the pieces of a big project effectively no matter the eventual solution.
Re:I want to fix programming
by protomyth on Tuesday January 24, 2012 @06:23PM
(#3507501)
although I respect Philip Greenspun greatly, most spreadsheets I have seen are pretty procedural. People tend to think in steps on those types of calculations.
I am not sure we are at the stage where the computer can be trusted with the "what". Most new learners need to be told step by step the "how" and computers seem to be at that stage. Prolog is a nice counter-example, but even it can get itself into some real trouble.
I agree programming is broken, and I agree the whole program knowledge is just painful, but I am think there are some steps before full declarative. As much as I dislike the old VB, it did have a very vibrant component market. That concept didn't seem to evolve or make it to the server. I look at Mongrel2 and wonder if the component approach could be applied. Regardless, I think the biggest problem is lack of ability to separate the pieces of a big project effectively no matter the eventual solution.